Can you configure two diff free goods items for one single
Item?
Example- on purchasing of item a u wants to give item b




Answers were Sorted based on User's Feedback



Can you configure two diff free goods items for one single Item? Example- on purchasing of item a u..

Answer / satya kiran

no it is not possible in sap

Is This Answer Correct ?    10 Yes 4 No

Can you configure two diff free goods items for one single Item? Example- on purchasing of item a u..

Answer / pradeep

Mr.Prasad
I think Ravi's concept is clear, but I have doubt on yours
concept.

Is This Answer Correct ?    7 Yes 2 No

Can you configure two diff free goods items for one single Item? Example- on purchasing of item a u..

Answer / rvk

Constraints

Free goods can only be supported on a 1:1 ratio. This means
that an order item can lead to a free goods item. Agreements
in the following form are not supported: ‘With material 1,
material 2 and material 3 are free of charge‘ or ‘If
material 1 and material 2 are ordered at the same time, then
material 3 is free of charge‘.

Free goods are not supported in combinations with material
structures (for example, product selection, BOM, variants
with BOM explosion).

Free goods are only supported for sales orders with document
category C (for example, not quotations).

Free goods are not supported for deliveries without
reference to a sales order.

Free goods cannot be used in make-to-order production,
third-party order processing and scheduling agreements.

If you defined a free goods for variants in a generic
article (only SAP Retail), you can only process the variants
in the purchase order and goods receipt individually (as
single articles). In other words, you cannot process them
using the generic article matrix.

Is This Answer Correct ?    7 Yes 2 No




Can you configure two diff free goods items for one single Item? Example- on purchasing of item a u..

Answer / prasad

Hi Pradeep

As per my Knowledge concern, BOM is a compound meterial
which is having main item n sub items.here i can give u an
example if take PComputer as a BOM, in that computer is the
main item and the remining are sub items(like mouse,key
board,moniter etc..). if u set ERLA in main item - item cat
grp, when u place the order it applys to whole met not for
the main item . means the sub items r not free items for
main item ,here sub item price is included in the main item
price so those sub items not free goods.

if u set the LUMF in main met- item cat grp, for each sub
item the price will be carried out.

This is BOM concept n its mainly focused on how the pricing
will be carried out during the sales order.(pls refer Glyn
c williams std SAP BOOK FOR SD)

HERE for above question posted by Debarati there is no
posability of configaration in standard SAP. U can give 2
no.s of same item(B or C) as free goods for met A.

hope u understand the concept.

Regards
PRASAD

Is This Answer Correct ?    4 Yes 4 No

Can you configure two diff free goods items for one single Item? Example- on purchasing of item a u..

Answer / rajiv trivedi

Hi,

As per SAP Lab free goods are not at all supported for more
than two items. Again suggetion of BOM to apply for free
goods are not valid.

Even as per Subha this can not be met by ABAPer to write
requiremtns & routine. This has been confirmed by SAP Lab
when we had asked in 2009.

SAP SD Certified Consultant

Is This Answer Correct ?    0 Yes 0 No

Can you configure two diff free goods items for one single Item? Example- on purchasing of item a u..

Answer / subha

hi rajiv

I agree that you cannot configure it in case the constion
type for free goods is exculsive but if it inclusive you
can do it

BUY 2 GET ONE FREE which we commanly see

SAI
Sr SAP CONSULTANT iN XENOSOFT TECHNNOLGIES INDIAD PVT LTD

Is This Answer Correct ?    0 Yes 0 No

Can you configure two diff free goods items for one single Item? Example- on purchasing of item a u..

Answer / rajiv trivedi

Hi Suba,

Many thoughts are emerging from various SAP experts. In
2006 we had directly contacted SAP Lab Wldorf Germany for
this issue. They wrote & confirmed that There is No
Solution for this supported by SAP. So even if some one
argue its not Valid at all.

I had been in SD & MM since last few years & I have
experienced same reply from very senior consultant.

SAP Functional Consultant
IBM PA USA

Is This Answer Correct ?    0 Yes 0 No

Can you configure two diff free goods items for one single Item? Example- on purchasing of item a u..

Answer / subha

Hi Rajiv

I agree on it but then the question remains same did you
ever try it out for inclusive goods . Please advice

Is This Answer Correct ?    0 Yes 0 No

Can you configure two diff free goods items for one single Item? Example- on purchasing of item a u..

Answer / rajiv trivedi

Free good is only for two items & not for more than that.

Tell me how will you configure 3 or more items in
Inclusive? If you can tell me steps or you try & if it is
working let me know.\\Thanks

Is This Answer Correct ?    0 Yes 0 No

Can you configure two diff free goods items for one single Item? Example- on purchasing of item a u..

Answer / mahesh

Hi
Yes, we are right SAP is not allow to process for free good with three materials

In this case,
create one order with free good material
Second order with free material
combined Two order with one delivery and do the billing

EX: order#xxx free good material line item 10(Tan) and 20(TANN)
order#yyy Total fee material line item 30(TANN)here we have change item cat. manually
combined this two order into one delivery and bill it

Is This Answer Correct ?    0 Yes 0 No

Post New Answer



More SAP SD (Sales & Distribution) Interview Questions

What is the function of NRAB condition type in free goods determination?

6 Answers  


Hi SD Experts, what is the difference between the Consignment Issue (CI) & Consignment Pick up (CP) with relation to Sales Document Types, item Categories & Schedule line Categories? Also give definition of both Consignment Issue & Consignment Pick Up along with detailed explanation in relation to its configuration & customization steps along with Business Scenarios? Explain in detail about how do you copy an existing Sales Document type CI & CP, how do you name it( Plz give Name key from your real time data) and what are the customizations you have done for your client? Do provide the document flow for both the Document Types CI & CP? Please provide as many real time data examples as many as possible with reference to your client/ Project? I have interview within 1-2 days? So, I request you to provide solutions to above question as early as possible? Your timely help would be greatly appreciated? Thanks in advance Regards

0 Answers   Satyam,


in third party customer raise the order qty 10. but vendor sent the goods qty 6 only.how can know the customer receiving quantity.

3 Answers   IBM,


In maintainance of automatic credit control ( tcode- ova8) in maintaining dynamic credit control wht is the procedure to change the horizon from months to weeks or days

5 Answers  


what is the difference between condition type EK01 (costs), PR00( basis price) and PBOO( gross price).can we apply all the three condition type in single sales order?

4 Answers  






Explain the various sections of ‘customer master record’.

0 Answers  


Tell me the basis / logic behind forming different Sales Organizations? Please provide answer to this question asap.. I am waiting for your reply eagerly. Expecting quick response from your end. Thanks in advance..

2 Answers   Cap Gemini,


i don't want to give a certain discount to a customer if he exceeds the credit limit. what customization i have to do for that?

4 Answers   IBM, Accenture,


What are different sales document in sap system?

0 Answers  


To perform material configure which system one has to use in a landscape?

3 Answers  


wat is single level BOM and multilevel BOM

1 Answers   IBM,


when you enter a sales order, you don't need to specify the sales area immediately. If you don't, where does the system automatically derive the sales area?

5 Answers  






Categories
  • SAP Basis Interview Questions SAP Basis (1260)
  • SAP ABAP Interview Questions SAP ABAP (3937)
  • SAPScript Interview Questions SAPScript (236)
  • SAP SD (Sales & Distribution) Interview Questions SAP SD (Sales & Distribution) (2688)
  • SAP MM (Material Management) Interview Questions SAP MM (Material Management) (901)
  • SAP QM (Quality Management) Interview Questions SAP QM (Quality Management) (99)
  • SAP PP (Production Planning) Interview Questions SAP PP (Production Planning) (523)
  • SAP PM (Plant Maintenance) Interview Questions SAP PM (Plant Maintenance) (252)
  • SAP PS (Project Systems) Interview Questions SAP PS (Project Systems) (138)
  • SAP FI-CO (Financial Accounting & Controlling) Interview Questions SAP FI-CO (Financial Accounting & Controlling) (2750)
  • SAP HR (Human Resource Management) Interview Questions SAP HR (Human Resource Management) (1179)
  • SAP CRM (Customer Relationship Management) Interview Questions SAP CRM (Customer Relationship Management) (432)
  • SAP SRM (Supplier Relationship Management) Interview Questions SAP SRM (Supplier Relationship Management) (132)
  • SAP APO (Advanced Planner Optimizer) Interview Questions SAP APO (Advanced Planner Optimizer) (90)
  • SAP BW (Business Warehouse) Interview Questions SAP BW (Business Warehouse) (896)
  • SAP Business Workflow Interview Questions SAP Business Workflow (72)
  • SAP Security Interview Questions SAP Security (592)
  • SAP Interfaces Interview Questions SAP Interfaces (74)
  • SAP Netweaver Interview Questions SAP Netweaver (282)
  • SAP ALE IDocs Interview Questions SAP ALE IDocs (162)
  • SAP Business One Interview Questions SAP Business One (110)
  • SAP BO BOBJ (Business Objects) Interview Questions SAP BO BOBJ (Business Objects) (388)
  • SAP CPS (Central Process Scheduling) Interview Questions SAP CPS (Central Process Scheduling) (14)
  • SAP GTS (Global Trade Services) Interview Questions SAP GTS (Global Trade Services) (21)
  • SAP Hybris Interview Questions SAP Hybris (132)
  • SAP HANA Interview Questions SAP HANA (698)
  • SAP PI (Process Integration) Interview Questions SAP PI (Process Integration) (113)
  • SAP PO (Process Orchestration) Interview Questions SAP PO (Process Orchestration) (0)
  • SAP BI (Business Intelligence) Interview Questions SAP BI (Business Intelligence) (174)
  • SAP BPC (Business Planning and Consolidation) Interview Questions SAP BPC (Business Planning and Consolidation) (38)
  • SAP BODS (Business Objects Data Services) Interview Questions SAP BODS (Business Objects Data Services) (49)
  • SAP BODI (Business Objects Data Integrator) Interview Questions SAP BODI (Business Objects Data Integrator) (0)
  • SAP Ariba Interview Questions SAP Ariba (8)
  • SAP Fiori Interview Questions SAP Fiori (45)
  • SAP EWM (Extended Warehouse Management) Interview Questions SAP EWM (Extended Warehouse Management) (58)
  • Sap R/3 Interview Questions Sap R/3 (149)
  • SAP FSCM Financial Supply Chain Management Interview Questions SAP FSCM Financial Supply Chain Management (101)
  • SAP WM (Warehouse Management) Interview Questions SAP WM (Warehouse Management) (31)
  • SAP GRC (Governance Risk and Compliance) Interview Questions SAP GRC (Governance Risk and Compliance) (63)
  • SAP MDM (Master Data Management) Interview Questions SAP MDM (Master Data Management) (0)
  • SAP MRS (Multi Resource Scheduling) Interview Questions SAP MRS (Multi Resource Scheduling) (0)
  • SAP ESS MSS (Employee Manager Self Service) Interview Questions SAP ESS MSS (Employee Manager Self Service) (13)
  • SAP CS (Customer Service) Interview Questions SAP CS (Customer Service) (0)
  • SAP TRM (Treasury and Risk Management) Interview Questions SAP TRM (Treasury and Risk Management) (0)
  • SAP Web Dynpro ABAP Interview Questions SAP Web Dynpro ABAP (198)
  • SAP IBP (Integrated Business Planning) Interview Questions SAP IBP (Integrated Business Planning) (0)
  • SAP OO-ABAP (Object Oriented ABAP) Interview Questions SAP OO-ABAP (Object Oriented ABAP) (70)
  • SAP S/4 HANA Finance (Simple Finance) Interview Questions SAP S/4 HANA Finance (Simple Finance) (141)
  • SAP FS-CD (Collections and Disbursements) Interview Questions SAP FS-CD (Collections and Disbursements) (0)
  • SAP PLM (Product Lifecycle Management) Interview Questions SAP PLM (Product Lifecycle Management) (0)
  • SAP SuccessFactors Interview Questions SAP SuccessFactors (33)
  • SAP Vistex Interview Questions SAP Vistex (0)
  • SAP ISR (IS Retail) Interview Questions SAP ISR (IS Retail) (28)
  • SAP IdM (Identity Management) Interview Questions SAP IdM (Identity Management) (0)
  • SAP IM (Investment Management) Interview Questions SAP IM (Investment Management) (0)
  • SAP UI5 Interview Questions SAP UI5 (59)
  • SAP SCM (Supply Chain Management) Interview Questions SAP SCM (Supply Chain Management) (51)
  • SAP XI (Exchange Infrastructure) Interview Questions SAP XI (Exchange Infrastructure) (49)
  • SAP Cloud Platform Interview Questions SAP Cloud Platform (34)
  • SAP Testing Interview Questions SAP Testing (89)
  • SAP SolMan (Solution Manager) Interview Questions SAP SolMan (Solution Manager) (63)
  • SAP MaxDB Interview Questions SAP MaxDB (116)
  • SAP GUI Interview Questions SAP GUI (15)
  • SAP AllOther Interview Questions SAP AllOther (328)