Interested to Buy Any Domain ? << Click Here >> for more details...
IN CIVIL ENGINEERING DESIGN WHY WE ARE USING LIMIT STATE
METHOD IS BEST?
I THINK WORKING STRESS METHOD IS BEST?
EX; FOR COLOUMN DESIGN IN LIMIT STATE METHOD AST
IS;1913SQ.MM
SAME TIME WORKING STRESS METHOD IS ;2213.
SO I THINK WORKING STRESS METHOD IS VERY STRONG COMPARE
THEN LIMIT STATE METHOD?
MY OPENING IS CORRECT OR NOT? PLS TO EXPLAIN SIRS
- 12 Answers
- 21679 Views
- I also Faced
- E-Mail Answers
Answers were Sorted based on User's Feedback
Answer / santosh singh
dear
what is u r qualification if ur a civil engineer this is a
stupid question.
see there is difference in working stress method and limit
state method
eg. if we design any member of building in case of working
stress method ie eg FOR 1000KN THERE IS DESIGN FOR ONLY
THIS LOAD
BUT in case of limit state method a factor of safety 1.5 is
used ie same member in limit state will be designed FOR
1.5 X 1000 = 1500KN
THUS THERE IS SAFETY IN DESIGN UR MEMBER CAN WITHSTAND LOAD
OF 1000KN BUT WE DESIGN IT TO WITHSTAND A LOAD 1500KN IE U
R STRUCTURE WILL NOT FAIL.
IF U DESIGN STRUCTURE FOR 1000KN LOAD AND ITS LOAD
CARRYING CAPACITY IS 1000KN THEN U R STRUCTURE WILL
COLLAPSE
THUS LIMITE STATE METHEOD IF BEST TODAY
IN 1900 WORKING STREE METHOD CAME
AFTER THAT ULTIMATE LOAD METHOD CAME
& THEN CAME LIMIT STATE METHOD
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 26 Yes | 1 No |
Answer / nithya
if you didn't know to explain this question dont sent
answer others wise explain briefly. my dear bond
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 25 Yes | 3 No |
Answer / rupesh belsare
in limit state method we are considering facorad load that
is in this method their is more factored of sefty than
workingstress mathod and one more reasone is that in limmt
state all kinds of limit is consider while designing e.g
limit state og bending, which is not considered in working
stress method
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 14 Yes | 0 No |
Answer / britto/ram/saravanan
in WORKING STRESS METHOD,(for ex, if we want to use M20
grade in any place we will use M15 grade), that is minimise
the characteristic strength of the material, this is taken
when u r in designing stage.
in LIMIT STATE METHOD (for ex, we have design a member
takes 1 ton in this method we take 1.5 ton) in this method
we will take the actual charateristic strengtn of the
material.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 15 Yes | 2 No |
Answer / s mukhopadhyay
Good Civil Engineers, before posting any answer, must also
write the matter in clear English for others to really
understand the content.Also, decency should always
maintained.
Limit state is definetely a superior version of design as
it guides to designing a structure considering all
eventualities and all overall structural failure conditions.
Regards,
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 4 Yes | 0 No |
Answer / santhosh kumar
dear
britto/ram/saravanan
pls to sent your mail id to santhoshselvamani@gmail.com
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 5 Yes | 3 No |
Answer / khan
in working stres method member is designed consedering
ultimate strength of the material where as in limit state
method members are designed considering yeilding strength
stress thats why members of less c/s area can be use
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 3 Yes | 3 No |
Answer / arif
in limit state method a factory of safety of 0.5 will be
considered (eg: for designing a colum of 1KN factor of
safety 0.5 will be multiplied hence it will become 1.5) so
column withstand even if it is loaded more than its required
capacity
in working stress method the column is designed only for 1
KN load.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 3 Yes | 3 No |
Answer / veera
working stress design is more conservative than limit state
method.concrete being a brittle material high factor of
safety is adopted (i.e-3).it is a stress approach,in case of
limit state partial factor of safety is used load is
factored and this a strain approach.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 1 Yes | 1 No |
Answer / somnath
In case of limit state method, before failure of any member it will show some sign like bending and also we considered a safe factor of safety
while in case of working stress method it will not show such signs.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 0 Yes | 0 No |
How to calculate the force on a column of three story building. What should be the base concrete height?.
For what purpose bedding is used under storm water drains?
what is the percentage of silt in black cotton soil.?
Define block?
how the calculatio is taken for shuttering in staircase.
1 Answers JMC Projects, Tech Mahindra, TechnoArt,
how much L is provide in footings. what is min and max length of L. what is the formula
What is a deep beam ? Explain ?
External staircase area outside the independant house includes in plinth area or not?
1M2=how much M3?
when we workout quantities of reinforcement steel , whate are the critari of lap length for column
how many cement in cubic feet of 40 kg bag white cement.
How and where are aqueducts built?
-
Civil Engineering (5086) - Mechanical Engineering (4456)
- Electrical Engineering (16639)
- Electronics Communications (3918)
- Chemical Engineering (1095)
- Aeronautical Engineering (239)
- Bio Engineering (96)
- Metallurgy (361)
- Industrial Engineering (259)
- Instrumentation (3014)
- Automobile Engineering (332)
- Mechatronics Engineering (97)
- Marine Engineering (124)
- Power Plant Engineering (172)
- Textile Engineering (575)
- Production Engineering (25)
- Satellite Systems Engineering (106)
- Engineering AllOther (1379)
