why the output sugnal is 4-20 ma and not 4-25 ma?

Answers were Sorted based on User's Feedback



why the output sugnal is 4-20 ma and not 4-25 ma?..

Answer / carl_ellis

Historically, the 4-20 mA electronic control signal replaced the 3-15 psi, 20-100 kPa or 0.2-1.0 bar pneumatic control signals and its competitor 10-50 mA.

The ratio of contorl signal span to its 'live zero' is the same in all cases: 4:1

The ratio of span to the 'live zero' for 3-15 psi is:
span = 12 psi (15-3)
live zero = 3
ratio span:live zero = 12:3 = 4:1

The ratio of span to the 'live zero' for 20-100 kPa is:
span = 80 psi (100-20)
live zero = 20
ratio span:live zero = 80:20 = 4:1

The ratio of span to the 'live zero' for 0.2-1.0 bar is:
span = 0.8 bar (1.0-0.2)
live zero = 0.2
ratio span:live zero = 0.8:0.2 = 4:1

The ratio of span to the 'live zero' for 10-50 mA is:
span = 40 mA (50-10)
live zero = 10 mA
ratio span:live zero = 40:10 = 4:1

The ratio of the span of the active control signal to its live zero is identical in all cases.

Carl Ellis
Measure First

Is This Answer Correct ?    5 Yes 1 No

why the output sugnal is 4-20 ma and not 4-25 ma?..

Answer / satish singh

because in this range the current value is continuity /or we can say that in thios range the value is linear

Is This Answer Correct ?    4 Yes 2 No

why the output sugnal is 4-20 ma and not 4-25 ma?..

Answer / sanju6192@gmail.com

if zero signal is send in process then there can be cable cut then not recognize that this is signal transmit or cutting signal

Is This Answer Correct ?    2 Yes 0 No

why the output sugnal is 4-20 ma and not 4-25 ma?..

Answer / marmikjani

Why we use 4-20mA signal?? Not start from 0-03mA? & 20mA??





· We can not use 0-20 mA signal cos then it becomes very difficult to distinguish between "zero" signal and "instrument fail" signal.



· Where as if we use 4-20 mA. its very easy like when we get 4mA means the signal is at low level and if it is below 4mA it shows us that the instrument is not working or it is failed




•That may have been one of those arbitrary decisions that is sometimes made when a standard is developed. In addition to providing a non-zero minimum to allow detecting signal loss, the minimum signal voltage provides for a margin between the minimum signal and any noise that might be present. Perhaps someone determined that 4ma was large enough to help with noise and thought that the numbers worked out conveniently. A 16 volt difference between min and max, difference = 4 X min, range of 20% to 100%, perhaps seemed easier to work with than 17 volts, 5.67 X min and 15% to 100% or 18V, 9 X & 10% to 100%


•This 20 mA signal is not enough to trigger a spark and therefore we can limit fire hazards in plant area


•As there is a leakage current so 0 to 3 MA, so we consider as 4-20MA. But in some cases we will find some transmitters 0-20MA which are more costly than 4-20mA

Is This Answer Correct ?    1 Yes 0 No

why the output sugnal is 4-20 ma and not 4-25 ma?..

Answer / carl_ellis

@Marmkijani
The main reason for 4-20mA is that 2-wire field instruments need to use 3.5mA to power their own electronics in order to make a measurement and to control the regulated output.

4-20mA is also, as you pointed out, a range in which the energy in the circuit is low enough to qualify for Intrinsic Safety approval (when used installed properly with an approved DC power supply and I/S barrier).

The "live zero" is nice and convenient as a diagnostic for an open circuit fault, but it was not the main reason for 4-20mA; powering field instruments was the main reason.

Is This Answer Correct ?    0 Yes 0 No

Post New Answer



More Instrumentation Interview Questions

How earthing can be checked????

0 Answers  


What are the different modes of a contollogix family processor? How they work?

3 Answers   Siemens, Honeywell,


what is the thermocuple compensation circuit

3 Answers  


Can anybody tell me which type of question are asked in the interview for the FORMULATION(Pharma) as a instrumentation engineer, & question in building managment system.

0 Answers   Reddy Labs, ScienceWay,


Can we use PLC in Hazardous Area?

2 Answers   MNHG,






What is T4 temperature in compressor?

1 Answers  


what are the levels of automation?

1 Answers  


what are the different types of Protocols? & their applications.

6 Answers   Infosys, Syntel, Sitara Chemical Industries, VSNL,


How do you measure g's?

5 Answers   HPCL, Thermax, GNFC, Polmon, Aramco,


What skill/s does the Instrument Technician has?

6 Answers  


pressure gauge measure static pressure or dynamic pressure?

3 Answers  


hi i want sov loop cheak from consol to field the operater given status to sov still no change, but MR room to sov ok so whats a problem and alreasy cheak all conection ok ?

2 Answers  






Categories
  • Civil Engineering Interview Questions Civil Engineering (5070)
  • Mechanical Engineering Interview Questions Mechanical Engineering (4442)
  • Electrical Engineering Interview Questions Electrical Engineering (16578)
  • Electronics Communications Interview Questions Electronics Communications (3915)
  • Chemical Engineering Interview Questions Chemical Engineering (1091)
  • Aeronautical Engineering Interview Questions Aeronautical Engineering (214)
  • Bio Engineering Interview Questions Bio Engineering (96)
  • Metallurgy Interview Questions Metallurgy (361)
  • Industrial Engineering Interview Questions Industrial Engineering (258)
  • Instrumentation Interview Questions Instrumentation (2986)
  • Automobile Engineering Interview Questions Automobile Engineering (332)
  • Mechatronics Engineering Interview Questions Mechatronics Engineering (97)
  • Marine Engineering Interview Questions Marine Engineering (122)
  • Power Plant Engineering Interview Questions Power Plant Engineering (170)
  • Textile Engineering Interview Questions Textile Engineering (575)
  • Production Engineering Interview Questions Production Engineering (0)
  • Satellite Systems Engineering Interview Questions Satellite Systems Engineering (106)
  • Engineering AllOther Interview Questions Engineering AllOther (1376)