what is the difference between SCADA and DCS?
Answers were Sorted based on User's Feedback
Answer / jeevana manickam
DCS- means Distribured Control systemm.This is mainly
process oriented system.If we ask the feedbeck from the
system,it will give from the IO field.This is a independent
control systen.
SCADA-means supervisory control and data acquisition
system.This is basically a data gathering system and given
the control based on that datas. This system will depends
PLC or DCS for its control.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 58 Yes | 5 No |
Answer / praveen kumar
SCADA is basically Remote area used, and its only data
gathering system and this system will depends on DCS for
controlling.
DCS is independent system, and this system will get
feedback and controlling also, SCADA can be added in DCS.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 33 Yes | 3 No |
Answer / khaled
DCS is a system distributed geographically and functionally
within the process areas. It can view and control the
porcess based on information received from process field
instrumentations and can do controlling through the human
machine interface or through logic built in the DCS
controllers.
SCADA, it is mainly a system in which the main controller
exist in the control room (master terminal unit) and
communicating with remote units (remote terminal units)
which gathering information from field
instrumentations.This system also can do controlling
through logic built in the main controller
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 12 Yes | 6 No |
Answer / asif iqbal
Traditionally, DCSs were large, expensive and very complex
systems that were considered as a control solution for the
continuous or batch process industries. In large systems
this is, in principle, still true today, with engineers
usually opting for PLCs and HMIs or SCADA for smaller
applications, in order to keep costs down.
A correctly designed DCS control system is essential for
the safe and efficient operation of a process plant.
Process Technical Services can provide qualified and
experienced instrument and control system engineers and
technicians that will review the P&I diagrams in detail to
determine if the DCS control system will meet the needs of
your operations.
SCADA Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition systems
which provide automation control over large industrial and
commercial operations providing real-time data transmission
by telemetry from remote location sensors for processing
and analysis resulting in a feedback loop for computerized
control over system operations
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 4 Yes | 1 No |
Answer / www.islamqa.com
# SCADA always consdered for monitoring and coordination,
but no control.
# DCS for monitoring and control.
# but now with great progress in technology, networking H/W
and telecommunication SCADA is now used in control also and
so the difference between the 2 systems will fade.
Regards,
Ahmed Sabry
Control and Instrumentation Engineer
GPC - General Petroleum Company
ahmedsabry.online@gmail.com
CELL.: 00 2 0121367310
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 0 Yes | 8 No |
Explain types of valves?
hi i'm an Instrumentation student,i have one doubt that we can call- > computer science as CS > Information science as IS > Electronics & communication as E & C In the same way what is short term for Instrumentation....?
why we are using drum level control valve air to close?
(1) In turbine, what does term CDP, NI, NH, HSSOC, means. (2) What is the purpose of LO overhead tank in turbines.(3) An equipment is certified for EEX, IA, IIC,T6, what do you under stand by this.(4) what is SURGE, and how it is prevented, what is the purpose of bypass valve across AS valve.(5) Give 2 application of quartz crystal used for process parameter measurement.(6) what is meant by cold float of compressor shaft. (7) state four different types of flow measurement. For gas flow measurement mmscfd is the common unit. Expand the unit and specify significance of word S in the unit.(8) what is meant by Gap voltage, in vibration measurement. Normally how much Gap voltage is set and state the reason.(9) what will the new flow factor if D/P transmitter is Re-Ranged from 25” wc to 50” wc.(10) what is the usage of QDV & Volume booster.
where cascade loop use ?
what is the formula for calculating milliampere at different pressure points for eg 4-20 ma = 3-15 psi but if i have to check the ma at 4.6 ma?
I have seen the Temperature element (T/C & RTD) installed in process line on 45 degree position, Why? What it mean? How many types of tapping position for temperature elements?
what is air to open and air to close control valve and difference btwn this...and how to measure milli amp by this...and what is the role of positioner and i/p converter in this..plz help me
What happen if I install my pressure transmitter below the elevation of pipe in natural gas service?
How to Calibrate variable Head flowmeter (Orifice), here we dont know High pressure and low pressure then how to apply pressure on HP and LP side ?
How to work mass flow meter ?
Why the Air Tank Accumulators required for the single acting actuators SDV's or BDV's as I see in some Schematic diagrams of ROTORK ??
Civil Engineering (5086)
Mechanical Engineering (4453)
Electrical Engineering (16638)
Electronics Communications (3918)
Chemical Engineering (1095)
Aeronautical Engineering (239)
Bio Engineering (96)
Metallurgy (361)
Industrial Engineering (259)
Instrumentation (3014)
Automobile Engineering (332)
Mechatronics Engineering (97)
Marine Engineering (124)
Power Plant Engineering (172)
Textile Engineering (575)
Production Engineering (25)
Satellite Systems Engineering (106)
Engineering AllOther (1379)