Why Transistors are not used as switching devices?
Answers were Sorted based on User's Feedback
Answer / sheril
because th swiching frequency will be low compared to others
|Is This Answer Correct ?||20 Yes||11 No|
Answer / jaipal
Transistors are not used as switching devices in the
elcectrical circuits because they can not with satnd for
high power ratings.
|Is This Answer Correct ?||11 Yes||10 No|
Answer / harsh zala
We can use transistor as a switching device but only for
low voltage application(for e.g electronic ckt)
If we want to use it in an electrical ckt, then we have to
go for higher current capacity, which are available upto
certain extent, but other switching devices are far more
cheper and responds good compare to it.
As we know it is current controlled device, so if we apply
large voltage diffrance or higher base current it can falsy
trigger, that is not desirable.
|Is This Answer Correct ?||4 Yes||3 No|
Answer / nakul khond
for using it as a switch we need to bias it properly we need
to use vcc,vbe this is very complicated and costly
instead we can use diode as a switch no need to bias easy
and cheap switch
|Is This Answer Correct ?||3 Yes||3 No|
Answer / biraj kundu
transistor are mainly current driven whle for switching are
done at high frequency and high voltage. thus devices like
SCR,IGBT,MOSFET,etc are used.
transistors are employed in small ckts
|Is This Answer Correct ?||3 Yes||5 No|
Answer / gnanbalaji
The above said answers are wrong.Recently power transistors
were developed.They can be used.Due to secondary breakdown,
conduction losses,they are not used frequently.Due to small
reverse leakage current they will turn ON automatically.
|Is This Answer Correct ?||4 Yes||6 No|
Answer / niranajn
since a transistor is bipolar as the conduction is due to
both electrons and holes
|Is This Answer Correct ?||1 Yes||3 No|
Answer / dr.anil
Actually, The question is incorrect. All of the transistors
can be used as a switch because transistors has current
on/off properties.There are 2 types of transistors one is
BJT(3 Terminal) and FETs(4 Terminal). BJT has low conduction
loss but has high switching losses whereas a FET
specially(IGBT or MOSFETs) have low sitching losses. That is
why MOSFET is preferred as switches instead of BJT in High
power, High Frequency applications.
|Is This Answer Correct ?||1 Yes||3 No|
Answer / amol
old days transister has hi switching &conduction loss,but
now days transister IGBT are used.
|Is This Answer Correct ?||3 Yes||7 No|
Answer / sathish.n tessolve
The reason why we are not using the transistor as
switching device because there is a chance of current flow
from VCC to ground when the transistor is ON.So the
transistor take more power.But this is never happen in the
CMOS device because only one transistor is get ON at a time.
|Is This Answer Correct ?||1 Yes||5 No|
Is there any relation between transformer capacity and its bdv?
what is the difference between thermal magnetic release and microprocessor based release breakers. what are the advantages of latter over the first one...
what is real power and reactive power?
How many sprinklers should be in one pipe line?
if an insulated power and control cables of a running gas diesel gensets laid direct in an open trench i.e, trench bed is not rcc of a power house in which rain water, spillage water alwas exists and all power control cables remains submerged even when gas gensets of 480 kw each runningin on load. These power &control cables runs from power house to switchgear room through these trenches in which water remains most of the time. pl explain its merit & de-merit
following are the questions asked in interviews: 1) Considering the short circuit fault, which switchgear is preferable, SFU OR MCCB? Which operates faster? whicg one is popular in Indian Market and why? 2)Define SCPD. What is type2 coodination? 3)Why the contactor rating is higher for the fuseless selection than for fuse selection? whether the ratinf of SFU or MCCB remains the same in both the cases? 4)If the HP rating is known then can you calculate the ratings of L.V Switchgear(SFU/MCCB, contactor, OLR) without using the selection chart?
What is the advisble power factor to be maintained in grid connecting power generation plnats without any effecting the generator.
specify the inbuilt protections in DG
please send me last 5 year interview questions
why vaccum circuit breakers are preferred over m.o.c.b
If i=10+10sin314t then find the rms and average value of current with explain?
two TG running in parallel at equal load.one TG CB tripped in reverse power relay.after tripping found its excitation was on & turbine running at rated speed.Please clearify why that TG tripped in reverse power ?