I have seen 1 video in which a person getting shock while
standing at top of a train,i have 1 question?
why the people sitting in the train doesn't get shock while
that man getting shock from top of the train? How the
earthing of train works?

Answers were Sorted based on User's Feedback



I have seen 1 video in which a person getting shock while standing at top of a train,i have 1 quest..

Answer / shashidara reddy

current will flow only when there is a difference in
potential(voltage difference),persn touches the wire is
between ground(zero potential) and the line (line
voltage ,usually 25000 volts ) . where as people in train
are at same potential(or as train body made of metal which
is good conductor bypasses all current) so no current and
no shock.

Is This Answer Correct ?    22 Yes 5 No

I have seen 1 video in which a person getting shock while standing at top of a train,i have 1 quest..

Answer / subrahmanyam

all the above answers are wrong since the frequency of the
Over head line (above the train) is 25 Hz and it is Ac
supply, if it is DC supply as in answer 3 how long it will
be supplied since DC supply cannot be supplied for a long
distances, since there will be voltage drops. you can
notice the substaions along with the railway lines, for DC
supplies there will not any substations, only generating
stations will be there.

Traction motors will be establised in the locomotive is DC
sereis motor, now you may ask about the supply since it is
AC supply with 25KV with 25Hz frequency the Rectifiers will
be used in the locomotive.

ANSWER 3 is correct in only tram way service that to with
24Volts DC supply.

now coming to why man was not elctrocuted in that video:

since it low frequency the field around conductor will less
and until unless he touches the line/conductor he will not
get effected. then about passengers before them when the
person was electrocuted the nearest substation to the
accident area will trip, that area will be isolated with in
Micro seconds. hence passengers will not get effected.

Is This Answer Correct ?    15 Yes 8 No

I have seen 1 video in which a person getting shock while standing at top of a train,i have 1 quest..

Answer / subashkumar

NO 9 Ans is excatly correct and all above are wrong because

the supply will pass through the shortest route the return

path and train body itself is the return path to the supply

the voltage is 25,000 V AC Supply the taken to train by

panthogragh and then converted in DC variable 900V to 0

by vairing the voltage only the speed can be varried.

if any quries reply chsubhash@yahoo.com

Is This Answer Correct ?    9 Yes 3 No

I have seen 1 video in which a person getting shock while standing at top of a train,i have 1 quest..

Answer / john

hi frnds...
first of all the charge inside any metal body is zero.
(.remember ur basic class lessons.)so when the man touch
the +ve line while the train is in gorund potential
(0 voltage) current starts flowing through his body,.

one more ex hav u ever seen a crow sittin on a single line
got eletricuted???? you could never see coz it is same
potential and there is no current flow through its body...
i hope u understand :)

Is This Answer Correct ?    5 Yes 0 No

I have seen 1 video in which a person getting shock while standing at top of a train,i have 1 quest..

Answer / subash

Dear all plese let you know that it is not a dc supply it

is AC supply.

Is This Answer Correct ?    4 Yes 1 No

I have seen 1 video in which a person getting shock while standing at top of a train,i have 1 quest..

Answer / ans 10 dickhead

answer 10 is absolutely wrong ...

Is This Answer Correct ?    2 Yes 0 No

I have seen 1 video in which a person getting shock while standing at top of a train,i have 1 quest..

Answer / prashant

THE RIGHT AND PERFECT ANSWER IS HERE.. WE KNOW THAT
CURENT FLOW THROUGH OUTSIDE OF THE TRAIN TO GROUND(LESS
RESISTENSE PATH),25000V TO 0V.SO PEOPLE SITTING IN THE
TRAIN DOESNOT GET SHOCK WHILE OTHERE MAN GETTING SHOCK FROM
TOP OF THE TRAIN.

Is This Answer Correct ?    2 Yes 1 No

I have seen 1 video in which a person getting shock while standing at top of a train,i have 1 quest..

Answer / kannan

The exact answer is

The rails are earthed at certain points which act as
neutral. Now the train which is on the rails is also at neutral.

A person touching neutral alone doesnt get electrocuted
(passengers inside train).

Person touching neutral as well as overhead line will get
severely electrocuted, so is the case of the person standing
on the train touching the HT overhead line.

As soon as the man touches the line heavy current starts
flowing through his body produces enough heat to burn his
body alive, even though the neutral tends to be at zero
potential which makes the passengers inside or outside
touching the train safe.

Hope this makes good sense..

Is This Answer Correct ?    2 Yes 1 No

I have seen 1 video in which a person getting shock while standing at top of a train,i have 1 quest..

Answer / k.s.s.srinivas

HI guys........

this is srinivas in my point of u

1.in train peopele sit inside the train doesn't get shocked
bec current comes in supply line (2500v) and return path is
ground if u touch neutral directly nouthing will happend.
this true.....

2.when man siting in top of the train touch the line
directly and stay in top of the train it will shocked bec
the current will flow to the earth through that person bec
circuit will closed.....
thats sall..
3.i was explain in 1 answer

in my point of view this is current if their is any
successions please tel me to my email.

Is This Answer Correct ?    1 Yes 1 No

I have seen 1 video in which a person getting shock while standing at top of a train,i have 1 quest..

Answer / veeranna gowda

train boby earth works for passangers and the man who is
standing on the train touch directly the conductor and the
voltage pass though his body so he died

Is This Answer Correct ?    2 Yes 4 No

Post New Answer

More Electrical Engineering Interview Questions

how to calculate the mesh earth network resistance in such substation, is there any recommended resistance values with references , thanks!

0 Answers   SRES,


types of motor starter

5 Answers  


Why open circuit test of transformers is conducted at rated voltage??Why not any other voltage??

0 Answers  


Which ciass CT can be use in diff. protection. Can be use 5p20?

5 Answers  


How to increase solar cell efficiency ?

1 Answers  






as per IE stranded what is max voltage between neutral to earth. 100 kva transformer neutral solid earth. min and max values i need to ans for RTI question

2 Answers  


what is mean by derating factor?

4 Answers   Essar,


Disadventage of cable-gland earthing if any ?

0 Answers  


how is control wiring coding is done in a CRP panel ?

0 Answers   Genus, Havells, Hindustan Power Projects,


(1)For 3 No 1500 KVA transformer require on one single bus bar or need to be section through bus coupler means upto 3MVA.(2) 22KV Net work system as ring, How maney I/C required or 0ne I/C and one O/G.(3) What should be rating of VCB for 22 KV line.(4)Electrical/mechanical inter lock, why we need.

0 Answers  


write encoder 17 pins details? pin a;b+, pin b;w+,..pin s & t. what is the meaning of b+, w+? explain;

0 Answers  


What is the difference between lubricating oil and insulating Oil?

4 Answers   Orchid,


Categories
  • Civil Engineering Interview Questions Civil Engineering (5085)
  • Mechanical Engineering Interview Questions Mechanical Engineering (4451)
  • Electrical Engineering Interview Questions Electrical Engineering (16632)
  • Electronics Communications Interview Questions Electronics Communications (3918)
  • Chemical Engineering Interview Questions Chemical Engineering (1095)
  • Aeronautical Engineering Interview Questions Aeronautical Engineering (239)
  • Bio Engineering Interview Questions Bio Engineering (96)
  • Metallurgy Interview Questions Metallurgy (361)
  • Industrial Engineering Interview Questions Industrial Engineering (259)
  • Instrumentation Interview Questions Instrumentation (3014)
  • Automobile Engineering Interview Questions Automobile Engineering (332)
  • Mechatronics Engineering Interview Questions Mechatronics Engineering (97)
  • Marine Engineering Interview Questions Marine Engineering (124)
  • Power Plant Engineering Interview Questions Power Plant Engineering (172)
  • Textile Engineering Interview Questions Textile Engineering (575)
  • Production Engineering Interview Questions Production Engineering (25)
  • Satellite Systems Engineering Interview Questions Satellite Systems Engineering (106)
  • Engineering AllOther Interview Questions Engineering AllOther (1379)