Why do we use solid shafts for transfer of power in case of
pumps/ turbines & other machines why we use a hollow shaft
(pipe) in universal joints of automobiles; although the
rated load and twist is approx. the same?
Answers were Sorted based on User's Feedback
Answer / shakeb azim
Because rpm of pumps & turbines is too high & at that speed
hollow shaft posses & face more torsional force, so it will
bend. That's why we use solid shaft insted of hollow shafts.
Is This Answer Correct ? | 17 Yes | 6 No |
Answer / karthick
becoz the torque transmitted by hollow shaft is more than
solid shaft.in automobiles the torque transmitted shd be
maximum thats why hollow shaft is preferred.
Is This Answer Correct ? | 9 Yes | 2 No |
Answer / vishnu
B'coz the hollow shaft can able to transmmite more torque
as comparing to solid shaft
Is This Answer Correct ? | 5 Yes | 0 No |
Answer / mc
Although the rated load and twist may be ~ the same, a "hollow shaft" (pipe) is used in universal joints of automobiles for several reasons. The "moment of inertia" of the entire section is reduced because of the fact that there is a decreased cross-sectional area. Pipe offers a high quality strength to weight ratio (Strong + Light Weight) which automobiles require to improve gas mileage. The deflection of a solid shaft compared to a pipe is insignificant, pipe offers a substantially larger tolerance of deflection.
Is This Answer Correct ? | 5 Yes | 0 No |
Answer / qawq
solid shafts are used in pumps/tubine because of transverse
load/stress .but in atuomobiles only torque are to be
transferred .
Is This Answer Correct ? | 3 Yes | 0 No |
Answer / jebaraj
This is bcoz in turbines there is uniform rpm in which the
shaft rotates except during starting and stopping whereas
in automobiles the rpm continuously changes and since
hollow shafts are used in automobiles
Is This Answer Correct ? | 0 Yes | 0 No |
Answer / gurpreet singh
because at core point of shaft,shear stress is zero,and this
part does not play any role to take load.
Is This Answer Correct ? | 0 Yes | 11 No |
Answer / narendra
in case of pipe joints we can't use solid shafts bcz in the
hollow shaft the liquid flows that,s why we cant use the
hollow shaft another thing is reducing the weight.
Is This Answer Correct ? | 0 Yes | 11 No |
Is Solid work and solid edge best programs for drawing? what is the difference bewteen them? r there better softwares?
What is the difference between blower and fan?
How to select the shock absorber?...................
We select 10mm nominal thickness for Elip head of a pressure vesel. The minimum thickness after forming is 8.2mm. (Shell thickness is 8mm. The minimum thickness after forming is satisfied or not with UG-79 (d)(3) in ASME SECTION VIII, Div.1?
why not maintain 7.0 ph in boiler ,when 7.0 is not acidic & not basic so why maintain 9+ ph?
For hot water : please compare to solar heat and heat pump (environment/operation/invest...) Is there any comparison available. Thank you
what is the electrical load for 1TR Ac?
Name two types of leak detectors and the method of application for each?
what is unit Ps ?
Why do 4 stroke engine uses valves while 2 stroke engine uses ports ????
which network in india earning more turn over per annum
What is the effect of inter cooling in gas turbines ?