why do we use 4-20mA as o/p and why don't use 0-20mA or 5-
21mA?

Answers were Sorted based on User's Feedback



why do we use 4-20mA as o/p and why don't use 0-20mA or 5- 21mA?..

Answer / ahmed eid

Ohm's law voltage = current * resistance
of the standerd voltage in the dcs from 1 to 5 voltge
and the standerd resistance of loop 250 oums
so
V=I*R
the first in the low signal 1 volt
1(v)=I*250(r) =.004 A
.004*1000 = 4 MA
the sacand in the high signal 5 volt
5(v)=I*250(r) = 020 A
.020*250 = 20 MA


Is This Answer Correct ?    19 Yes 0 No

why do we use 4-20mA as o/p and why don't use 0-20mA or 5- 21mA?..

Answer / d tilston

Two wire transmitters require some power to work. 0-20 mA
would not provide any power at 0 mA.

Power = current x volts, (usually 24 VDC)
Power = 0.004A x 24VDC
Power = 0.096W

Not much power.

Is This Answer Correct ?    4 Yes 0 No

why do we use 4-20mA as o/p and why don't use 0-20mA or 5- 21mA?..

Answer / carl_ellis

Question:
why do we use 4-20mA as o/p and why don't use 0-20mA or 5- 21mA?

There are systems that use 0-20mA as an output from a
controller. Those are active', powered outputs, not
signals from 2 wire, loop powered field transmitters. 2
wire, loop powered instruments use about 3.5mA to power the
transmitter's electronics, so 2 wire, loop powered
instruments can never go below 3.5mA without losing the
current needed to power the instrument.

An active analog output from a controller that uses the
controller's power from the controller to drive the current
signal can be a 4-20mA signal or a 0-20mA signal.

People in the process industries use the 4-20mA output
because it is a 'live-zero' that immediately indicates a
broken wire or an open circuit if the loop current falls to
0.0mA. Those using 0-20mA probably have a 0-10Vdc or 0-5Vdc
analog input and want to use the entire span with a 500 ohm
or 250 ohm resistor.

As to why 5-21mA is not used, there are conventions used
that make systems maintainable over time. If every analog
output used oddball ranges or spans, it would be near
impossible to maintain the system over time. Given that
many control systems operate in excess of 10 years, it is
important to use standard analog signals in order to keep
the system maintainable.

The convention is 4-20mA, established by the ISA SP-50
standard in 1967. Deviations are punishable. Be warned.

Carl Ellis
Measure First

Is This Answer Correct ?    1 Yes 0 No

Post New Answer

More Instrumentation Interview Questions

key exchanges in wpa,wpa2,tls

0 Answers  


For what Wake Frequency Calculation is used?

3 Answers   Reliance,


Q- What are the application in which PNP transistor is preferred over NPN ?

0 Answers  


Why 4-20 amps is being used in instruments? Why cant we use any other range instead of 4-20 amps? Why only 4 amps is taken as lower limit and why 20 amps is taken as the higher limit?

0 Answers  


in the boiler in the main steam line and its bypass line and the startup vent vales are only motorised valves why cant we use other types of valves such as pneumatic.

3 Answers  






What's the Installtion procedure of DP Transmitter for Gas,steam and water?

2 Answers  


what is bms?

4 Answers   Emco,


how to measure the output of RTD given the general formula of  rtd.  

2 Answers  


Why we use 250 ohm resister in series hart communicator?

3 Answers   Thermax,


Sir,I am going to sit for IOCL written test exam. recently.Can anyone tell me the name of 'Objective type Question Book on Instrumentation Engineering ' which will help me. Pl. mail to bidyut_71@rediffmail.com / bidyut.saha2008@indiatimes.com / bidyut.saha09@yahoo.in

0 Answers  


Why would an Engineer consider combining FEEDBACK and FEEDFORWARD control in some applications?

4 Answers   Jindal,


What is standard of DCS panel design?and what is step of DCS panel design?wiring and type of connector(screw or DB connector)

0 Answers  


Categories
  • Civil Engineering Interview Questions Civil Engineering (5085)
  • Mechanical Engineering Interview Questions Mechanical Engineering (4451)
  • Electrical Engineering Interview Questions Electrical Engineering (16632)
  • Electronics Communications Interview Questions Electronics Communications (3918)
  • Chemical Engineering Interview Questions Chemical Engineering (1095)
  • Aeronautical Engineering Interview Questions Aeronautical Engineering (239)
  • Bio Engineering Interview Questions Bio Engineering (96)
  • Metallurgy Interview Questions Metallurgy (361)
  • Industrial Engineering Interview Questions Industrial Engineering (259)
  • Instrumentation Interview Questions Instrumentation (3014)
  • Automobile Engineering Interview Questions Automobile Engineering (332)
  • Mechatronics Engineering Interview Questions Mechatronics Engineering (97)
  • Marine Engineering Interview Questions Marine Engineering (124)
  • Power Plant Engineering Interview Questions Power Plant Engineering (172)
  • Textile Engineering Interview Questions Textile Engineering (575)
  • Production Engineering Interview Questions Production Engineering (25)
  • Satellite Systems Engineering Interview Questions Satellite Systems Engineering (106)
  • Engineering AllOther Interview Questions Engineering AllOther (1379)