Why we not use 2-20Ma or 1-20Ma

Answers were Sorted based on User's Feedback



Why we not use 2-20Ma or 1-20Ma..

Answer / sai kiran.c

very goood my dear frnd ....actualy wat u said is
rite...itzz a usualy universal standard.
BUT ALSO ONE REASON STARTING FROM 4ma IS THAT THE DEVICE
WILL WRK IN OPTIMUM RESPONSE FRM THAT RANGE.
& MOSTLY AND ALSO IT NEVR STARTS FRM ZERO BCOZ IT DOESNT
MEAN THE DEVICE IS IN REST POSITION OR NOT.
WE CANT JUDGE THE DEVICE IS IN ON OR OFF.

Is This Answer Correct ?    10 Yes 1 No

Why we not use 2-20Ma or 1-20Ma..

Answer / j jones

Sai Kiran.c is correct is saying that we don't start from 0mA because we need a "Live Zero" this is so that if the control loop goes open circuit we have an indication of this.

why do we use 4-20mA, not 1 or 2mA - 20mA, well simply just as in a pneumatic system we use 5-15psi, (0.2-1bar) it gives us the most linear output, and above that, if we were to use 1mA, any induced voltages from eddie currents in cables running alongside could cause a mA to be produced by the resistance of the cable, so our readings would be affected, and if we amplify the signal, the amplification has to be greater as we have to amplify 1mA more than a 4mA signal

Is This Answer Correct ?    2 Yes 1 No

Why we not use 2-20Ma or 1-20Ma..

Answer / carl_ellis

Answer 1 is correct. The ISA SP50 standard established
4-20mA worldwide as the analog control signal decades ago.

But what the answer 1 and the others miss is that using 1 or
2 mA at the low end would not provide sufficient power to
power 2 wire loop powered instruments.

2 wire loop powered instruments use about 3.6mA at 24Vdc to
power the electronics which makes the measurement and
controls the output circuitry. That's about 85mW, not a lot
of power.

1mA or 2mA of current would provide only a fraction of 85mW
available at 4mA for powering the instrument itself, and
reduce the functionality of 2 wire loop powered instruments.

Carl Ellis
Measure First

Is This Answer Correct ?    1 Yes 0 No

Why we not use 2-20Ma or 1-20Ma..

Answer / larry thompson

As with all analog loop standards the range must be divisible by 4 so the technician can determine which quartile the signal is (25%, 50%, 75%, 100%) in. 4 mA was deemed the minimum current necessary to power most analog signal transmitters (it had previously been 10 to 50 mA)

Is This Answer Correct ?    0 Yes 0 No

Why we not use 2-20Ma or 1-20Ma..

Answer / suvankar haldar

because 4to20mA is a universal& Used mostly in all factories

Is This Answer Correct ?    4 Yes 16 No

Post New Answer

More Instrumentation Interview Questions

What is the use of temperature compensation?

0 Answers  


what is bevel? why bevel required in orifice plate?

2 Answers  


explain key exchanges in all security modes WPA,WPA2,TLS?

0 Answers  


WHAT IS INSTRUMENTATION?

17 Answers   ITC Infotech,


flow transmeter accuracy 0.075% of full scale & find ucertainty is 0.025 % so what is maximum limit band of uncertainty

0 Answers   ONGC,






how many types of spped sensors n vibration sensors?their basic principle n connection?

0 Answers   IOCL, ITC Infotech,


how to calculate interface capelary level transmetar lower S.G.0.54 and uper S.G. 0.26 and h=490 mm

3 Answers  


i want to know for good instrument engineer or success how many software knowledage required & from which university

0 Answers  


what is the diffrence between LCN and UCN

2 Answers  


Instrumentation engineer please reply me,I am electrical engineer ,what is the future in instrumentation dept {presently working (P&ID) Design} for me,whether good future for me as instrumentation department.what side can i get job in future

3 Answers  


An electronic p controller has an input range of 1-5v, and output range of 4-20mA, while testing a step change of 0.4 was applied at the input , the PB setting was 50% ,what should be the change in the output ?

1 Answers   Reliance,


difference between repeatability and reproductability

1 Answers   IOCL,


Categories
  • Civil Engineering Interview Questions Civil Engineering (5085)
  • Mechanical Engineering Interview Questions Mechanical Engineering (4451)
  • Electrical Engineering Interview Questions Electrical Engineering (16632)
  • Electronics Communications Interview Questions Electronics Communications (3918)
  • Chemical Engineering Interview Questions Chemical Engineering (1095)
  • Aeronautical Engineering Interview Questions Aeronautical Engineering (239)
  • Bio Engineering Interview Questions Bio Engineering (96)
  • Metallurgy Interview Questions Metallurgy (361)
  • Industrial Engineering Interview Questions Industrial Engineering (259)
  • Instrumentation Interview Questions Instrumentation (3014)
  • Automobile Engineering Interview Questions Automobile Engineering (332)
  • Mechatronics Engineering Interview Questions Mechatronics Engineering (97)
  • Marine Engineering Interview Questions Marine Engineering (124)
  • Power Plant Engineering Interview Questions Power Plant Engineering (172)
  • Textile Engineering Interview Questions Textile Engineering (575)
  • Production Engineering Interview Questions Production Engineering (25)
  • Satellite Systems Engineering Interview Questions Satellite Systems Engineering (106)
  • Engineering AllOther Interview Questions Engineering AllOther (1379)