Why we not use 2-20Ma or 1-20Ma

Answer Posted / carl_ellis

Answer 1 is correct. The ISA SP50 standard established
4-20mA worldwide as the analog control signal decades ago.

But what the answer 1 and the others miss is that using 1 or
2 mA at the low end would not provide sufficient power to
power 2 wire loop powered instruments.

2 wire loop powered instruments use about 3.6mA at 24Vdc to
power the electronics which makes the measurement and
controls the output circuitry. That's about 85mW, not a lot
of power.

1mA or 2mA of current would provide only a fraction of 85mW
available at 4mA for powering the instrument itself, and
reduce the functionality of 2 wire loop powered instruments.

Carl Ellis
Measure First

Is This Answer Correct ?    1 Yes 0 No



Post New Answer       View All Answers


Please Help Members By Posting Answers For Below Questions

Why upper weighing limit of electronics balance is 90% of the total weighing capacity?

1668


May I have a brief note above the voltage barriers? Whats is the purpose? Please mail me if you've operational details, mail id: rajkumar.diice@gmail.com

1607


Explain the combusion chamber

1574


What is the start up procedure of desalter

3040


Which Signal hart communicator work? If there any signal change when hart connect while transmitter in line ?

928






Calibration procedure for electro magnetic flow meter

1536


what is difference between HOT permit and cold permit

1604


installation process of orifice,a question asked for confusion creation in interview by BARC 1.if orifice is tightly fitted with pipe ,it will act like venturi 2.if orifice is left hanging in between liquid it will not create the pressure difference exactly,

1667


In VVVF DRIVES VOLTAGE IS ALSO VARY WITH THE FREQUENCY. HOW? WHAT IS THE DIRECT FORMULA RELATING THESE TWO.

1894


Explain Gas Turbine startup and shutdown sequences

3814


A length of steel pipe is used to carry sea water to a desalination plant. An adequate corrosion allowance must be specified and indicated in the piping specification, which affects the _________________________ of the pipe

1784


how to do dynolab wind speed sensor loop test, how to simulate value,i have simulate mA 4-20mA but not responding in DCS faceplate, please kindly advice me any one.

564


Q1: Consider part of a control loop, which excludes the transmitter, consisting of a process, a controller and a control valve which may be represented by two dead times of 0.5 min each and three exponential lags of 0.8 min., 1.0 min. and 1.5 min. respectively. We wish to express this system as an overall first order plus dead time (FOPLD) model ie gain, time constant and process dead time. (We will see later that this is often done, to simplify controller tuning). For this exercise, gain is considered to be 1.0. (A) If the transmitter is a flow transmitter whose behaviour can be described by a dead time of 0.2 min. and an exponential lag of 0.5 min. in terms of the overall dead time and overall first order lag how can the system behaviour be approximated ? Overall dead time = Overall time constant = (B) If the transmitter is a temperature transmitter with a temperature sensor in a protecting well whose behaviour can be described by a dead time of 0.7 min. and an exponential lag of 15 min. how can the overall system behaviour be approximated now? Overall dead time = Overall time constant =

1446


in differential pressure transmitter,min&max pressure range for hp&lp

1533


what is sil (safety integrity level

2195