Jim lies a lot. He tells the truth on only one day in a week.
One day he said: "I lie on Mondays and Tuesdays."
The next day he said: "Today is either Sunday, Saturday or
Thursday."
The next day he said: "I lie on Fridays and Wednesdays."
On which day of the week does Jim tell the truth?
Answers were Sorted based on User's Feedback
Answer / guest
Jim tells the truth on Tuesday.
As Jim tells truth only on one day in a week, his statement
on day 1 and day 3 both can not be false. Otherwise he tells
truth on more than one days in a week. Also, all three
statements are mad on three consecutive days, statement made
on day 1 and day 3 both can not be true. Thus, either the
statement made on day 1 or day 3 is true and other is false.
Also, the statement made on day 2 must be false i.e. day 1
is not Saturday, Friday or Wednesday.
Let's assume that the statement 1 is true. Then from the
statement 3, day 1 must be either Friday or Wednesday. But
it is already deduced that day 1 is not Saturday, Friday or
Wednesday.
Hence, the statement made on day 1 is false and the last
statement is true. then from the statement 1, day 3 must be
either Monday or Tuesday. But it is already deduced that day
1 can not be Saturday i.e. day 3 can't be Monday. Hence, Jim
tells the truth on Tuesday.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 35 Yes | 4 No |
Answer / manish kumar yadav
Stmt 1 = He lies on Monday and Tuesday.
stms 2 = on next day "Today is sunday,saturday or thusday.
stmt 3 = on next day "he lies on Friday and wednesday.
Assume he tells truth on day X and remember he lies on (X+1) th and( X+2) th day.
------------------------------
If the day X = Monday
------------------------------
stmt1 : he lies on monday, so on the same day he cannot tell that he lies or say truth.
because if he says he lies on monday if he was suppose to say truth on tuesday it will be contradicting in same manner if he was to lie on that day but he tells truth. so X cannot be Monday
-------------------
if X= Tuesday
--------------------
same as above...
----------------------------
if X = Wednesday
----------------------------
then X+1 and X+2 day he must lie.
so what he tells on x+1 day is next day can be sunday, saturday, Thursday. Here next day is Thursday so this condition is false.
---------------------------
if X = Thursday
----------------------------
X+1 day will be Friday and what he tells on X+1 th day is "Today is sunday,saturday or thusday"(HE LIES HERE)((TRUE)) so in accordance to our assumption this condition is true for us
and on X+2 th day will be Saturday (For this one Read below)
in stmt 3 he told today is friday or wednesday so as taking the same condition as monday and tuesday he cannot say truth or lie on Friday or wednesday i.e if X+2 id friday or wednesday he cannot do anything so in above X+2 our assumption fits well and he lies on Saturday too.
-----------------------------------------
if X= Friday Explained as above
----------------------------------------
if X= Saturday (if he says truth on saturday)
--------------------------------------------------
then X+1 will be Sunday but acc to stmt 2 our assumption fails because what he told is true and he cannot tell truth on two days.
----------------------------
if X= Sunday
----------------------------
then X+1 must be Monday.
and on X+2 day must be wednesday but stmt 3 fits well with what he said and he can say truth on only one day in a week either monday or sunday so this condition also fails ....
=============================Conclusion=============
so only solution is X= thursday...
HE DOESN'T LIE ON THURSDAY
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 8 Yes | 2 No |
Answer / imran sajjad
the above answer:
if statement of day 1 is false then 'i lie on mondays' is
false, implies that on monday he tells the truth also.
if either of statement 1 and 3 is a lie, that means he
tells the truth on two days.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 5 Yes | 5 No |
Answer / kashif
if first day is sunday..
1st day he tells i lie on monday and tuesday...assume he is telling truth.
2nd day is tells today is sunday,saturday,or thursday...means he is lying because today is monday so 1st statement is true partially...
3rd day- he tells i lie on fridays.that is also false..
2 and 3 satisfy 1 ...hence is saysn truth on sunday
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 1 Yes | 1 No |
Answer / alice clevland
well because he lies, how do you know he is telling the
truth when he says all these things. This could be a trick
question that couldnt be answered.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 2 Yes | 5 No |
Please send the SBI Clerical Post model question paper.
0 Answers State Bank Of India SBI,
1. at the recent web developers bowling match, two games weree played. kiev beat stuart in both games; also richard beat john in both games. The winner in game 1 came second in game 2. richard won game 2 and john beat stuart in game1. no player got the saame placing twice. can you determine who finished where in each game?
A, B and C are three points on a straight line, not necessarily equidistant with B being between A and C. Three semicircles are drawn on the same side of the line with AB, BC and AC as the diameters. BD is perpendicular to the line ABC, and D lies on the semicircle AC. If the funny shaped diagram between the three semicircles has an area of 1000 square cms, find the length of BD.
what is the difference between point and dot?
19 Answers BVC, TCS,
how do i improve my logical questions. is there any website?
P pages read in d mins after day p+1 pages read in d+1 mins last day 379 pages done in 317 mins find p+4
Ship is 180 miles away from shore. At that time a plane started from shore to pass some information to the ship with 10 times velocity of ship's velocity. At what distance from shore they will meat?
The cricket match between India and Pakistan was over. ? Harbhajan scored more runs than Ganguly. ? Sachin scored more runs than Laxman but less than Dravid ? Badani scored as much runs as Agarkar but less than Dravid and more than Sachin. ? Ganguly scored more runs than either Agarkar or Dravid. Each batsman scored 10 runs more than his immediate batsman. The lowest score was 10 runs. How much did each one of them score
Jack and Jill are playing cards for a stake of $1 a game. At the end of the evening, Jack has won 3 games and Jill has won $3. How many games did they play?
1. There are six columns of coins and there are eight coins in each column. One of the columns is entirely of fake coins and other five columns contain real coins. Weight of one fake coin is 1 gm more than the real coin which is 50 gm. How you can tell which column contains fake coin by single weight? 2.You want to purchase a two wheeler. You got three options from the counter. 1) Pay Rs. 40,400 on single payment 2) Pay Rs. 20,000 now and remaining by two equal annual installment of Rs. 11,600 3) Pay Rs. 15,000 now and remaining by three equal annual installment of Rs. 10,000 Which option is most attractive? (Take annual interest rate 9%)
What is the four-digit number in which the first digit is 1/3 of the second, the third is the sum of the first and second, and the last is three times the second?
1 bird ko fish se pyar ho gaya. wo dono mile to kaise? fish paani ko chhod nahi sakti aur bird paani me ja nahi sakta.