Can I write COMMIT and ROLLBACK in user-exit?

Answers were Sorted based on User's Feedback



Can I write COMMIT and ROLLBACK in user-exit?..

Answer / bikas

Hi,

ofcourse we can write but it is not recommended.

In an user exit control is in the mid of a transaction data
will be updated or not is decided at the end of the
execution of the transaction.

If we write Commit it will commit the database update
whereas case may be like transaction went into error and
database update is not required in that case there will be
data inconsistancy.

Is This Answer Correct ?    16 Yes 1 No

Can I write COMMIT and ROLLBACK in user-exit?..

Answer / krishna davuluri

Hi,

Coomit and Roll back in the User exit should not be used.
Because while executing userexit its not allways sure that
all needed values for database updations are present or
not.hence we should not use COMMIT or ROLLBACK, of work.
Also userexit is expected to add new functionality to
existing functionality, its not supposed to make any
changes in the existing functionality.

Suppose if you take Userexit SAVE_DOCUMENT_PREPARE.Systems
goes through the user exit more than once and COMMIT or
ROLLBACK may cause inconsistencies.

Is This Answer Correct ?    11 Yes 2 No

Can I write COMMIT and ROLLBACK in user-exit?..

Answer / buddula15

Hi

I think that we should not write COMMIT in user exit but we can
write ROLLBACK. Correct me if i am wrong.

Is This Answer Correct ?    3 Yes 10 No

Can I write COMMIT and ROLLBACK in user-exit?..

Answer / malli.gontla

generally user exits are used for add the additional
functionality to the sap standard code. it will not effect
to future software upgradation.

but how commit and rollback is used in user exits.

Is This Answer Correct ?    0 Yes 12 No

Post New Answer

More SAP ABAP Interview Questions

What are the data types of the abap/4 layer? : abap data dictionary

0 Answers  


What is an rdbms?

0 Answers  


What are two methods of modifying sap standard tables? : abap data dictionary

0 Answers  


use of chain and endchain?

1 Answers   Accenture,


what are the stpes in ALE?

2 Answers   Satyam,






What is the relationship existing between the various data elements in data dictionary? : abap data dictionary

0 Answers  


please any one can tell me modifytable keyword used in DDIC? what is a basic diffrence between modify table and update key word?

4 Answers   KPIT,


1 . how do u design technical documentation in abap ? 2 . what u currently devloped in sap abap ?

0 Answers   Bristle Cone,


What is the main point while using control break in internal table ?

3 Answers  


where can u use secondary index in program please tell me? is there any tool to test in development client?is there any performance tool is thre pleaseeee tell me?

3 Answers   Cap Gemini,


list some middlewares used in EDI ?

3 Answers  


How to change standard data base table ?

1 Answers  


Categories
  • SAP Basis Interview Questions SAP Basis (1262)
  • SAP ABAP Interview Questions SAP ABAP (3939)
  • SAPScript Interview Questions SAPScript (236)
  • SAP SD (Sales & Distribution) Interview Questions SAP SD (Sales & Distribution) (2716)
  • SAP MM (Material Management) Interview Questions SAP MM (Material Management) (911)
  • SAP QM (Quality Management) Interview Questions SAP QM (Quality Management) (99)
  • SAP PP (Production Planning) Interview Questions SAP PP (Production Planning) (523)
  • SAP PM (Plant Maintenance) Interview Questions SAP PM (Plant Maintenance) (252)
  • SAP PS (Project Systems) Interview Questions SAP PS (Project Systems) (138)
  • SAP FI-CO (Financial Accounting & Controlling) Interview Questions SAP FI-CO (Financial Accounting & Controlling) (2766)
  • SAP HR (Human Resource Management) Interview Questions SAP HR (Human Resource Management) (1180)
  • SAP CRM (Customer Relationship Management) Interview Questions SAP CRM (Customer Relationship Management) (432)
  • SAP SRM (Supplier Relationship Management) Interview Questions SAP SRM (Supplier Relationship Management) (132)
  • SAP APO (Advanced Planner Optimizer) Interview Questions SAP APO (Advanced Planner Optimizer) (92)
  • SAP BW (Business Warehouse) Interview Questions SAP BW (Business Warehouse) (896)
  • SAP Business Workflow Interview Questions SAP Business Workflow (72)
  • SAP Security Interview Questions SAP Security (597)
  • SAP Interfaces Interview Questions SAP Interfaces (74)
  • SAP Netweaver Interview Questions SAP Netweaver (282)
  • SAP ALE IDocs Interview Questions SAP ALE IDocs (163)
  • SAP Business One Interview Questions SAP Business One (110)
  • SAP BO BOBJ (Business Objects) Interview Questions SAP BO BOBJ (Business Objects) (388)
  • SAP CPS (Central Process Scheduling) Interview Questions SAP CPS (Central Process Scheduling) (14)
  • SAP GTS (Global Trade Services) Interview Questions SAP GTS (Global Trade Services) (21)
  • SAP Hybris Interview Questions SAP Hybris (132)
  • SAP HANA Interview Questions SAP HANA (700)
  • SAP PI (Process Integration) Interview Questions SAP PI (Process Integration) (113)
  • SAP PO (Process Orchestration) Interview Questions SAP PO (Process Orchestration) (25)
  • SAP BI (Business Intelligence) Interview Questions SAP BI (Business Intelligence) (174)
  • SAP BPC (Business Planning and Consolidation) Interview Questions SAP BPC (Business Planning and Consolidation) (38)
  • SAP BODS (Business Objects Data Services) Interview Questions SAP BODS (Business Objects Data Services) (49)
  • SAP BODI (Business Objects Data Integrator) Interview Questions SAP BODI (Business Objects Data Integrator) (26)
  • SAP Ariba Interview Questions SAP Ariba (9)
  • SAP Fiori Interview Questions SAP Fiori (45)
  • SAP EWM (Extended Warehouse Management) Interview Questions SAP EWM (Extended Warehouse Management) (58)
  • Sap R/3 Interview Questions Sap R/3 (150)
  • SAP FSCM Financial Supply Chain Management Interview Questions SAP FSCM Financial Supply Chain Management (101)
  • SAP WM (Warehouse Management) Interview Questions SAP WM (Warehouse Management) (31)
  • SAP GRC (Governance Risk and Compliance) Interview Questions SAP GRC (Governance Risk and Compliance) (64)
  • SAP MDM (Master Data Management) Interview Questions SAP MDM (Master Data Management) (0)
  • SAP MRS (Multi Resource Scheduling) Interview Questions SAP MRS (Multi Resource Scheduling) (0)
  • SAP ESS MSS (Employee Manager Self Service) Interview Questions SAP ESS MSS (Employee Manager Self Service) (13)
  • SAP CS (Customer Service) Interview Questions SAP CS (Customer Service) (0)
  • SAP TRM (Treasury and Risk Management) Interview Questions SAP TRM (Treasury and Risk Management) (0)
  • SAP Web Dynpro ABAP Interview Questions SAP Web Dynpro ABAP (198)
  • SAP IBP (Integrated Business Planning) Interview Questions SAP IBP (Integrated Business Planning) (0)
  • SAP OO-ABAP (Object Oriented ABAP) Interview Questions SAP OO-ABAP (Object Oriented ABAP) (70)
  • SAP S/4 HANA Finance (Simple Finance) Interview Questions SAP S/4 HANA Finance (Simple Finance) (143)
  • SAP FS-CD (Collections and Disbursements) Interview Questions SAP FS-CD (Collections and Disbursements) (0)
  • SAP PLM (Product Lifecycle Management) Interview Questions SAP PLM (Product Lifecycle Management) (0)
  • SAP SuccessFactors Interview Questions SAP SuccessFactors (33)
  • SAP Vistex Interview Questions SAP Vistex (0)
  • SAP ISR (IS Retail) Interview Questions SAP ISR (IS Retail) (28)
  • SAP IdM (Identity Management) Interview Questions SAP IdM (Identity Management) (0)
  • SAP IM (Investment Management) Interview Questions SAP IM (Investment Management) (0)
  • SAP UI5 Interview Questions SAP UI5 (59)
  • SAP SCM (Supply Chain Management) Interview Questions SAP SCM (Supply Chain Management) (51)
  • SAP XI (Exchange Infrastructure) Interview Questions SAP XI (Exchange Infrastructure) (49)
  • SAP Cloud Platform Interview Questions SAP Cloud Platform (34)
  • SAP Testing Interview Questions SAP Testing (89)
  • SAP SolMan (Solution Manager) Interview Questions SAP SolMan (Solution Manager) (63)
  • SAP MaxDB Interview Questions SAP MaxDB (116)
  • SAP GUI Interview Questions SAP GUI (15)
  • SAP AllOther Interview Questions SAP AllOther (329)