You have 13 balls which all look identical. All the balls
are the same weight except for one. Using only a balance
scale, can find the odd one out with only 3 weighings?
Is it possible to always tell if the odd one out is heavier
or lighter than the other balls?
- 9 Answers
- 36038 Views
- Sapient, I also Faced
- E-Mail Answers
Answers were Sorted based on User's Feedback
Answer / guest
It is always possible to find odd ball in 3 weighings and in
most of the cases it is possible to tell whether the odd
ball is heavier or lighter. Only in one case, it is not
possible to tell the odd ball is whether heavier or lighter.
1. Take 8 balls and weigh 4 against 4.
o If both are not equal, goto step 2
o If both are equal, goto step 3
2. One of these 8 balls is the odd one. Name the balls on
heavier side of the scale as H1, H2, H3 and H4. Similarly,
name the balls on the lighter side of the scale as L1, L2,
L3 and L4. Either one of H's is heavier or one of L's is
lighter. Weigh (H1, H2, L1) against (H3, H4, X) where X is
one ball from the remaining 5 balls in intial weighing.
o If both are equal, one of L2, L3, L4 is lighter. Weigh L2
against L3.
? If both are equal, L4 is the odd ball and is lighter.
? If L2 is light, L2 is the odd ball and is lighter.
? If L3 is light, L3 is the odd ball and is lighter.
o If (H1, H2, L1) is heavier side on the scale, either H1 or
H2 is heavier. Weight H1 against H2
? If both are equal, there is some error.
? If H1 is heavy, H1 is the odd ball and is heavier.
? If H2 is heavy, H2 is the odd ball and is heavier.
o If (H3, H4, X) is heavier side on the scale, either H3 or
H4 is heavier or L1 is lighter. Weight H3 against H4
? If both are equal, L1 is the odd ball and is lighter.
? If H3 is heavy, H3 is the odd ball and is heavier.
? If H4 is heavy, H4 is the odd ball and is heavier.
3. One of the remaining 5 balls is the odd one. Name the
balls as C1, C2, C3, C4, C5. Weight (C1, C2, C3) against
(X1, X2, X3) where X1, X2, X3 are any three balls from the
first weighing of 8 balls.
o If both are equal, one of remaining 2 balls is the odd
i.e. either C4 or C5. Weigh C4 with X1
? If both are equal, C5 is the odd ball. But you can not
tell whether it is heavier or lighter.
? If C4 is heavy, C4 is the odd ball and is heavier.
? If C4 is light, C4 is the odd ball and is lighter.
o If (C1, C2, C3) is heavier side, one of C1, C2, C3 is the
odd ball and is heavier. Weigh C1 and C2.
? If both are equal, C3 is the odd ball and is heavier.
? If C1 is heavy, C1 is the odd ball and is heavier.
? If C2 is heavy, C2 is the odd ball and is heavier.
o If (C1, C2, C3) is lighter side, one of C1, C2, C3 is the
odd ball and is lighter. Weigh C1 and C2.
? If both are equal, C3 is the odd ball and is heavier.
? If C1 is light, C1 is the odd ball and is lighter.
? If C2 is light, C2 is the odd ball and is lighter.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 48 Yes | 10 No |
Answer / rahul khanduri
Little difficult, I found the soln then I forgot, and I am too lazy to right it here, so basically you have to use little brain, you have to think that if one side is heavy this can't be because of this and that, I think op got my ans.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 0 Yes | 2 No |
Devide these 13 balls into 3 categories i.e 6,6,1. Then measure both 6 and 6 . You will find the result. If both are equal then off one is the left out ball. If not equal then make another separate to the less weight 6 ball into 3 and 3. Same way measure these 3 and 3 . Find out the less weight side. Again separate this three into 1,1,1. Then measure any 2. You will find the needed result.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 2 Yes | 5 No |
Answer / atul saxena
Yes it is always possible to tell if the odd ball is heavier or lighter than the other balls with only three weighings.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 1 Yes | 5 No |
Answer / kamran khan
13 balls are divide into four group (3,3,3,3,1)
1)First measure one pare of (3,3) . If it is equal then measure an other part
if it is also equal then last one is defective .
you suppose to first measure is unequal then unequal portion take and pick up on ball i.e(measure 1,1) and one is taken out if both are same then taken out ball is defective otherwise between two any one is defective
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 1 Yes | 8 No |
Answer / vinay tyagi
first of all it is necessary that we must know that
the odd ball is heavy or light than others.
Ans. suppose odd ball is heavy.
divide balls among three group abruptly
I 6 balls
II 6 balls
III 1 ball
now measure group I against II
1. if equal then odd ball is III grop
2 if not equal then odd ball is in heavier side
3. now from the heavier side 6 ball , just divide them into
two groups of 3 ball each
4. measure these groups and find the heavier one
5 now we have 3 ball , just choose two balls and measure
against each other, we can find the heavier one if found equal then third ball is the odd one
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 5 Yes | 13 No |
Answer / mohit kaushik
divide 13 in 4(I) , 4(II) , 4(III) , 1
1.) weigh I against II if equal
2.) weigh I against III if equal , the ball left is defective.
after performing step 1. and 2. in either of the step the
scale is not balanced.
Suppose it is not balanced in case 1 .( You can consider
case 2. if u like )
took any two balls from case 1 & weigh against each other.
if equal defective ball must be in group of other two.
take any ball from other group if scale is equal the ball
left is defective or else the chosen ball from the group of
two is defective.
By : mohit
Provide feedback
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 6 Yes | 16 No |
Answer / nitin verma
The question is incomplete
at least one of the thirteen balls should be given as known correct weighing ball separately.
Then only it can be solved correctly.
And it is actually much more difficult than it look to be.
And there is only one way to start I.e keeping 5 balls on both sides with one known ball on any side and rest 3 aside.
Your question is incomplete or wrong
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 2 Yes | 12 No |
Answer / nitin phunsukh wangru verma
How simple
you guys are such a JACK ASS
read the question carefully
the right answer is
No it not possible to catch the faulty ball all the time with exact fault I.e light or heavy
but it is a good question and can be asked in a better way
as I said earlier.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 2 Yes | 16 No |
A, B and C are three points on a straight line, not necessarily equidistant with B being between A and C. Three semicircles are drawn on the same side of the line with AB, BC and AC as the diameters. BD is perpendicular to the line ABC, and D lies on the semicircle AC. If the funny shaped diagram between the three semicircles has an area of 1000 square cms, find the length of BD.
what is the value of (x-a)(x-b).............(x-z)?
2 Answers Infoview, Vernalis Systems,
Vipul was studying for his examinations and the lights went off. It was around 1:00 AM. He lighted two uniform candles of equal length but one thicker than the other. The thick candle is supposed to last six hours and the thin one two hours less. When he finally went to sleep, the thick candle was twice as long as the thin one. For how long did Vipul study in candle light?
*suppose u have 2 distribute a sum rs 50 among 30 studnt .it is also decided that a male student will get double than of female student.find the no. of male n female student of class?
My friend collects antique stamps. She purchased two, but found that she needed to raise money urgently. So she sold them for Rs. 8000 each. On one she made 20% and on the other she lost 20%. How much did she gain or lose in the entire transaction?
A B C D E F G H I Each of the digits from 1 to 9 is represented by a different letter above. Also, A + B + C = C + D + E = E + F + G = G + H + I = 13 Which digit does E represent?
If you added together the number of 2's in each of the following sets of numbers, which set would contain the most 2's: 1-333, 334-666, or 667-999?
Three convicts are brought into the warden's office. He says he can parole one of them and to decide which one he will parole he takes out 5 hats (3 red and 2 white). He stands behind them and places a hat on each one of their heads and puts the other two remaining hats in a drawer. He tells the prisioners they can look at the others hats and if they can tell which hat they have on they will be the one who is paroled. The first man looks at the other two and says, "I don't know." The second man looks at the others hats and says, "I don't know." The third man who is blind says, "Even though I have not the gift of sight I can tell by what the others have said that the color of my hat is..." What color is the blind mans hat and how does he know?
2 Answers Bally Technologies, Walkover, Wipro,
You have 14 apples. Your Friend Marge takes away 3 and gives you 2. You drop 7 but pick up 4. Bret takes 4 and gives 5. You take one from Marge and give it to Bret in exchange for 3 more. You give those 3 to Marge and she gives you an apple and an orange. Frank comes and takes the apple Marge gave you and gives you a pear. You give the pear to Bret in exchange for an apple. Frank then takes an apple from Marge, gives it to Bret for an orange, gives you the orange for an apple. How many pears do you have?
Its come one in a year and twice in a week. What is this?
What is the smallest whole number that, when divided by 2, leaves a remainder of 1; when divided by 3, leaves a remainder of 2; and so on, up to leaving a remainder of 9 when divided by 10?
24 Answers ASD Lab, Athena Health Care,
A cube is divided into 125 pieces.. then four columns are removed then coloured all side black.. i) how many 0 side painted cubes? ii) how many 1 side painted cubes? iii) how many 2 side painted cubes? iV) how many 3 side painted cubes? V) how many 4 side painted cubes?
7 Answers Stairway Engineering, Tata Elxsi,
English 
