A man holds a gun up to your head and says "shoot your father or I'll kill you both". You then shoot. Are you guilty of murder?What about if he had said "shoot your father or I'll kill you".Finally, what about it he had said "shoot your father or I'll kill him".



A man holds a gun up to your head and says "shoot your father or I'll kill you both"...

Answer / Rakesh Kumar Vishwakarma

Under duress, the perpetrator may have a potential defense against murder charges. However, each case varies depending on jurisdiction and circumstances. In the first scenario, both victims could be considered as threatened, potentially reducing guilt to manslaughter. In the second scenario, the threat is only directed at the shooter, making the justification for self-defense more tenuous. The third scenario does not involve a direct threat against the shooter.

Is This Answer Correct ?    0 Yes 0 No

Post New Answer

More Law AllOther Interview Questions

Should judges have a legislative role?

1 Answers  


why are the laws are so phophorus?

1 Answers   TATA,


Many times law enforcement are certain that a particular crime has been committed by a defendant. What is your response if there is not enough evidence to stand at a criminal trial?

1 Answers  


i am a doctor,but i haven't started practicing yet.i was preparing for all-india entrance exam for 2 years.am i supposed to pay professional tax for these 2 years,when i wasn't even employed??? plz reply..

1 Answers  


The judge may give a lighter sentence than the victim and or community believe are fair. How you address the victim or community's concern regarding the sentence?

1 Answers  


how one can prove statutory auditors liability according tp indian law?

1 Answers  


best way to claim compensation through slander false accusations

1 Answers  


I have purchased bitumen from outside state. please confirm whether i have to pay difference vat on purchases value apart from entrytax

1 Answers  


There are three partners in a partnership firm. The firm has office premises in the name of firm. Depreciation on this asset is charged every in the books of the firm. Now after depreciation the book value of this assets has become Rs. 1000. Whereas the market vakue of this premises id Rs. 10 crorer. To bring this property at MV the partners revalued this premised at Rs. 8 crorers in the books of the firm and accordingly credited partner's capital account in their profit sharing ratio. My questions are as under. What is the income tax liability of the firm on revaluation? What is the income tax liability of partner of each partner on revaluation and credit to his capital account. In future whether depreciation to the firm is allowed on revalued amount under the income tax act. What happens to the tax liability if one partner withdraw his entire capital from the firm which includes credit on revaluation of office premises? When partners can withdraw out of their credit balance in their capital account without attracting any tax liability either by the firm or by partner? What happens if one partner retires and he gets amount equal to his capital account which inclides credit on account of revaluation? is there any tax liability to the retiring partner?

1 Answers  


We are manufacturer for Export material , and Material cleared without payment of Excise duty Notification No. 43/2001 Dtd. 06.06.2001 of Rule 19 of C.E. Rule 2002. Can I Purchase Raw Material Under above Rule

1 Answers  


A manufacturing defect stops a parachute from deploying in a charity skydive leading to two people dying. Is this manslaughter or murder?

1 Answers  


Fill in the blank Income tax act-----------

4 Answers  


Categories