Among 12 identical looking golf balls there is one that is defective in weight. It is either heavier or lighter than the standard one. You have a balance. You can only weigh 3 times to find out which one is defective and whether it is heavier or lighter.
- 5 Answers
- 13768 Views
- I also Faced
- E-Mail Answers
Answers were Sorted based on User's Feedback
Answer / swati
In order to explain better, give each ball a number, said from 1 to 12. We also use ball zero to indicate a standard ball if that ball is identified as a standard ball.
Step 1. Take 8 balls to weight, ball 1, 2, 3, and 4 on the left, ball 5, 6, 7, and 8 on the right.
If they are balanced, go to Step 2-1.
If they are not balanced, go to Step 2-2.
Step 2-1.
At this time, you know the ball 1 to 8 are OK. Take ball 9, 10 and 11, plus a standard ball - ball zero. Just assume you have ball zero and 9 on the left and ball 10 and ball 11 on the right.
If they are balanced, go to Step 3-1.
If left side is heavier, go to step 3-2.
If right side is heavier, go to Step 3-3.
Step 2-2.
At this time, you know the ball 9 to ball 12 are standard balls. Assume the left side is heavier. Now you need to take 6 balls to weight the second time. You need to choose a standard ball - ball zero, ball 6 which might be lighter, and ball 3 which might be heavier, put them on the left side. Also you choose ball 2 which might be heavier, ball 5 and 7 which might be lighter. Notice that we change sides for ball 2 and ball 6.
If they are balanced, go to step 3-4.
If the left side is heavier, go to step 3-5.
If the right side is heavier, go to step 3-6.
Step 3-1.
From step 2-1, we know ball 9, 10 and 11 are standard balls. We just need to determine the ball 12 is heavier or lighter. We put a standard ball on the left, put ball 12 on the right.
If right side is heavier, the ball 12 is heavier.
If the right side is lighter, the ball 12 is lighter
Step 3-2.
From step 2-1, you know that either ball 9 is heavier, or one of statements should be true: the ball 10 is lighter or the ball 11 is lighter. We can put the ball 10 on the left, the ball 11 on the right.
If they are balanced, they should be OK, the ball 9 is heavier.
If the ball 10 is heavier, the ball 10 is Ok, ball 11 is lighter.
If the ball 10 is lighter, then the ball 11 is OK.
Step 3-3.
From Step 2-1, you know that either ball 9 is lighter, or one of statements should be true: the ball 10 is heavier or the ball 11 is heavier. We can put the ball 10 on the left, the ball 11 on the right.
If they are balanced, they should be OK, the ball 9 is lighter.
If the ball 10 is lighter, the ball 10 is Ok, ball 11 is Heavier.
If the ball 10 is heavier, then the ball 11 is OK.
Step 3-4.
From Step 2-2, you know ball 2, 3, 5, 6, 7 are standard balls. You can determine the ball 1 or ball 4 is heavier, or ball 8 is lighter. We can put ball 1 on the left and the ball 4 on the right.
If they are balanced, we are sure the ball 8 is lighter.
If the ball 1 is lighter, the ball 1 is Ok and ball 4 is heavier.
If the ball 4 is lighter, the ball 4 is OK, the ball 1 is heavier.
Step 3-5.
From Step 2-2, you know ball 2 and ball 6 are OK, because the change side does not affect the consequence. You can determine the ball 3 is heavier, or one of the statements is true: ball 5 is lighter or the ball 7 is lighter. We can put ball 5 on the left and the ball 7 on the right.
If they are balanced, we are sure the ball 3 is heavier.
If the ball 5 is heavier, the ball 5 is Ok and ball 7 is lighter.
If the ball 7 is heavier, the ball 7 is OK, the ball 5 is lighter.
Step 3-6.
From step 2-2, you know that the weighting result is changed because the ball 2 and ball 6 are exchanged. It really means that either ball 2 is heavier or ball 6 is lighter. You still have one more weight, I am sure you know how to do it!
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 4 Yes | 3 No |
Answer / amit
Make 4 groups of 3 balls each (G1, G2, G3, G4. Picturing a decision tree structure may help as I explain below.
1st Weighing: Place G1 and G2
If Equal then: defective ball in G3 or G4 (Consequently G1 & G2 contain balls all having the same weight i.e. normal balls or control group)
If Not Equal then: defective ball in G1 or G2 (Consequently G3 & G4 contain balls all having the same weight i.e. normal balls or control group)
Assume 1st Weighing is Equal.
2nd Weighing: Place G3 (test) and G1 (control)on pans
If Equal then: defective ball is in G4
If Not Equal then: defective ball in G3. Now if G3 is heavier (pan goes down) that means the abnormal ball is heavier than all others. If G3 is lighter (pan goes up) then that means the abnormal ball is lighter than all others.
Assume 2nd Weighing is Not Equal and G3 group is heavier.
Now we name the 3 balls in G3 group as G3-1, G3-2, G3-3.
3rd Weighing: Place G3-1 and G3-2 on pans.
If Equal then: The G3-3 is the defective (and heavier ball).
If Not Equal then: Then ball in the pan that goes down (i.e. heavier ball) is the defective one.
So 1st Weighing - Narrowing the test group
2nd Weighing - Determining heavy/light status
3rd Weighing - Determining abnormal ball
At any place above depending upon the outcome (Equal / Not Equal) you will have to change the Group in the next weighing accordingly. (E.g. Assume 2nd Weighing was equal then defective ball in G4 - so 3rd weighing you follow same procedure described above with the G4 balls).
I was stumped when I first came across this. And I found no perfect answers online. But some attempts by others helped me figure out part of the solution. Finally I found the missing part (2nd weighing finding heavy/light is crucial and 3rd Weighing with individual balls).
Since many people may be struggling with this - I thought I should help by posting the solution. Test it and vote up if its right!
Cheers!
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 3 Yes | 4 No |
1. take and put 6 ball on each side of the scale
2. One side will be heavier Try #1
3. Take the heavier side and put 3 balls on each side of
side of the scale. one side is heavier Try #2
4. you now have 3 balls. Take and place one ball on each
side of the scale. If one is the heavier ball the scale
will show it. If the scale measures the same then to ball
in your hand is the heavier. Try #3
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 4 Yes | 7 No |
Answer / anand
first take 3 balls on one side of the scale and another 3
balls on the other side of the scale. If they don’t weigh
equal then the defective ball is here in this bunch.if they
weigh equal then defective ball is in the set of other 6
balls.Thus we have 6 balls in which we need to find out the
defective one.
now the bunch of other six balls are equal weighted..take 3
balls of from them and weigh them with the bunch of 3 balls
of the above weighted, if they are equal then defective ball
is in the other bunch of 3 balls and if they are not equal
defective ball is in this 3 ball set.(if this set weighs
heavier than the ideal group of 3 balls {that we have
selected from the remaining set of 6 balls} than defective
ball is heavier and vice versa.
now we have 3 balls..take any 2 and weigh them with the
other equal set of 2 balls..if they weigh equal then the
remaining ball is defective..and if they don’t weigh equal
then the ball which is heavier(as we have assumed the set if
3 is heavier than ideal set in the second step.) is
defective in the scale..
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 9 Yes | 20 No |
Answer / neelesh patil
First take 6 balls on one side of the scale and another 6
balls on the other side of the scale. The defective ball will be there in one of this bunch. Consider the bunch which is Imbalanced. Again weight that 6 balls in the Bunch of 3 balls on one side of the scale and another 3 balls on the other side of the scale. Again Considering the imbalanced weight.weight the ball Single-Single if it is balanced then defective is remaining ball.
in these way we can complete in 3 steps.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 4 Yes | 22 No |
Somebody marked the six faces of a die with the numbers 1, 2 and 3 - each number twice. The die was put on a table. Four people - Abu, Babu, Calu and Dabu - sat around the table so that each one was able to see only three sides of the die at a glance. ? Abu sees the number 1 and two even numbers. ? Babu and Calu can see three different numbers each. ? Dabu sees number 2 twice and he can't remember the third number. What number is face down on the table?
If a rook and a bishop of a standard chess set are randomly placed on a chessboard, what is the probability that one is attacking the other? Note that both are different colored pieces.
When Alexander the Great attacked the forces of Porus, an Indian soldier was captured by the Greeks. He had displayed such bravery in battle, however, that the enemy offered to let him choose how he wanted to be killed. They told him, "If you tell a lie, you will put to the sword, and if you tell the truth you will be hanged." The soldier could make only one statement. He made that statement and went free. What did he say?
A drinks machine offers three selections - Tea, Coffee or Random (Either tea or Coffee) but the machine has been wired up wrongly so that each button does not give what it claims. If each drink costs 50p, how much minimum money do you have to put into the machine to work out which button gives which selection?
If you started a business in which you earned Rs.1 on the first day, Rs.3 on the second day, Rs.5 on the third day, Rs.7 on the fourth day, & so on. How much would you have earned with this business after 50 years (assuming there are exactly 365 days in every year)?
Eleven boys and girls wait to take their seats in the same row in a movie theater. There are exactly 11 seats in the row. They decided that after the first person sits down, the next person has to sit next to the first. The third sits next to one of the first two and so on until all eleven are seated. In other words, no person can take a seat that separates him/her from at least one other person. How many different ways can this be accomplished? Note that the first person can choose any of the 11 seats.
Gomzi has 3 timepieces in his house - a wall clock, an alarm clock and a wristwatch. The wristwatch is always accurate, whereas the wall clock gains 2 minutes everyday and the alarm clock loses 2 minutes everyday. At exactly midnight last night, all three watches were showing the same time. If today is 25 July 2003, then on which date all three clocks will show the same time again?
There are 3 lights (in one room) and 3 swtiches (in another room), one for each, if you only enter into the light room once. How can you find out which switch corresponds to which light?
Find a number which ends with digit 2 such that when you cut this last digit and paste it in the front of the number, the new number value is double that of original.
At ADVANTAGE, all inhabitants are liar; but not all the time. Males speak the truth in the morning and lie in the afternoon. Females lie in the morning and speak the truth in the afternoon. Three inhabitants are asked the time of day. Two are female and one is male. They respond as follow: A. If asked, B would claim it is morning. B. If asked, C would claim it is morning. C. If asked, A would claim it is afternoon. Is it morning or afternoon? What is the gender of each inhabitants?
suppose you build a tower interlocking cubes that is 99 cubes high. And suppose you have to paint each square on the tower. How many squares would you have to paint?
Two people enter a race in whick you run to a point and back. Person A runs 20 mph to and from the point. Person B runs to the point going 10 mph and 30 mph going back. Who came in first?
English 
