What is the minimum number of races required to pick the
best three horses from 25 horses if each race has maximum of
5 horses?

Answer Posted / diepark

An explanation as to why the answer is 7, assuming no method
to time the races:

Divide the 25 horses into groups of 5 labeled A to E. Hold 5
races, one for each group and label the horses A1, A2, etc.,
where the number designates what place the horse finished.
Hold a 6th race out of the five winners of each group, and
arbitrarily pick A1 as the winner, B1 as second place, etc.
After the 6th race, you'll have the following tree for
fastest horse:

A1
| \
A2 B1
| | \
A3 B2 C1
| | | \
A4 B3 C2 D1
.
.
.

As you can see, A1 is the fastest horse and is faster than
all the horses in the other groups since he beat their
winners, and likewise, B1 is faster than the horses in
groups C to E since he beat their winners. But we don't know
if B1 is faster than the rest of the horses in group A,
since they never raced against each other, and likewise, we
don't know if C1 is faster than the remaining horses in
group B, since they didn't race each other, etc. To
determine the 2nd fastest horse, let's hold a hypothetical
7th race between A2 and B1. There are two possible outcomes
that result in the following trees:

A1 A1
| |
B1 A2
/ | \ / |
A2 B2 C1 A3 B1
| | | | | \
A3 B3 C2 A4 B2 C1

In the first outcome (left tree), B1 has won and is the
second fastest horse. Now we need to find out which horse is
3rd fastest in an 8th race between A2, B2, and C1, since
they have never raced each other.

In the second outcome (right tree), A2 has won and is the
second fastest. Therefore, an 8th race needs to happen
between A3 and B1 to determine the 3rd fastest horse.

If you consider which horses run in the hypothetical 7th and
8th races (horses A2, A3, B1, B2, and C1), you'll notice
that only 5 horses need to race, so all 5 horses can
actually run in the 7th race to determine the 2nd and 3rd
fastest horses.

So, is it possible to find the top 3 fastest horses in only
6 races? Yes, there are certain situations where this is
possible. Take the scenario where the winner always gets to
run in the next race: the first race has 5 horses (Group F)
that haven't raced; the winner goes on to race 4 more horses
that haven't raced (Group E), and that winner gets to race 4
more (Group D), etc. until the 6th and last race (Group A).

As long as the winner from the 5th race does not finish in
1st or 2nd, then you can determine the 3 fastest horses;
otherwise, you won't be able to determine the 2nd and/or 3rd
fastest horses, since the horses in group A have not raced
any of the other horses.

Race 1(F) 2(E) 3(D) 4(C) 5(B) 6(A)
----------------------------------------------------
1st F1-. E1----->E1-._ C1. B1-. A1
2nd F2 \ E2 D1 `->E1 \ B2 \ A2
3rd F3 `->F1 D2 C2 \ B3 `->B1
. F4 E3 D3 C3 `->C1 A3
. F5 E4 D4 C4 B4 A4

Thus, to guarantee you can determine the fastest 3 horses,
you need 7 races.

Is This Answer Correct ?    11 Yes 2 No



Post New Answer       View All Answers


Please Help Members By Posting Answers For Below Questions

how soon can you travel down to start your new job?

2234


There is puzzle with the word "CONSTANTINE" and exactly don't know the question if anybody knows the Q&A plz send it ahmed.basha.munna@gmail.com

2468


4 cards are placed on a table, each card has two colors. U don't know the color of the back side of eachcard.4 persons A B C and D are sitting on the table before the cards. They can see Red, Green Red and blue.Out of the 4 poeple 2 always lie. They see the color on the reverse side and give the following comment A: Yello/green B: Neither Blue/nor Green c: Blue/Yello D: Blue/ Yello find out the color on the other side of the 4 cards. No. of animals is 11 more than the no. of birds. If the no. of birds were the no. of animals and no. of animals were the no. of birds( ie., interchanging no.s of animals and birds.), the total no. of legs get reduced by one fifth (1/5). How many no. of birds and animals were there?

834


Three members are hunting in a forest.While crossing a streem cartridges of two of them gets wetted up.Then the third person decides his cartidges equally. After 4 shots of each person, total cartridges remaining are equal to what each had initially after sharing.How many total cartridges they initially they shared?

962


P pages read in d mins after day p+1 pages read in d+1 mins last day 379 pages done in 317 mins find p+4

2014






foot is related to man in the same way hoof is related to...........

1951


IDear sir, I have had a data containing of 4 numbers on daily basis for which I would like to know what is the next comming 4 numbers. Based on that data I would like to find out the next comming numbers. Support needed. regards chandramohan gudivada 09849974512 cm116_99@yahoo.com Example : 4513, 4132, 1465, 2941, 1762, 1432, 3412, 5283, 7261, 2643, 4751, 2581, 6513 .... and what is the next number in the sequence?

2207


What is the syllabus for numerical aptitude exam to be held by the United bank of India. Plz inform me through email. Thanking You!

2455


In a soap company a soap is manufactured with 11 parts. For making one soap you will get 1 part as crap. At the end of the day u have 251 such scraps. From that how many soaps can be manufactured?

1071


At 6o'clock ,a watch strokes 6 times.The time between first and last is 30secs.At midnight 12o' clock how much time for all strokes?

1010


what job position/s are you currently holding with your current employer?

2683


why should we hire the others waiting to be interviewed?

2447


In rail road there are some stations. Each station should have tickets to all other stations.If they add some new stations they need 46 more tickets.How many stations are there before and after adding the stations?

770


what three specific job positions do you target from qatar airways group u.k?

2684


sir i need generalKnowledge previous questions for rrb secunderabad goods guard exam

2235