What are the difference between C-Curve and D-Curve for
MCB's.

Answer Posted / simon

Awesome thread with a lot of almost correct and mostly
correct answers.

The challenge is knowing to which standard a particular
breaker was manufactured.

AS/NZS 4898 specifies:
B Curve between 3 In and 5 In
C Curve between 5 In and 10 In
D Curve between 10 In and 14 In

This was an update to AS 3947.2 which specified:
B Curve between 3.2 In and 4.8 In
C Curve between 7 In and 10 In
D Curve between 10 In and 14 In

The application notes in #11 and #13 are pretty much spot on.

Now lets assume we're only using AS/NZS 4898 breakers.
Lets assume we're using a Clipsal C60 10A B curve breaker.

The breaker should operate electromagnetically (<0.2s)with
an inrush current greater than 30A (3 x 10A).
The same 10A breaker however with 15A of current will not
trip electromagnetically but will trip thermally between 30
and 600 seconds after load is applied.

A C curve breaker of the same type should not operate
electromagnetically at either 15A or 30A. It should operate
thermally between 30 and 1000 seconds after a 15A load is
applied and between 6 and 50 seconds after a 30A load is
applied.

Note the distinct difference between and instantaneous /
electromagnetic trip and a delayed / thermal trip.

Is This Answer Correct ?    10 Yes 4 No



Post New Answer       View All Answers


Please Help Members By Posting Answers For Below Questions

what is the difference between active power and reactive power and apparant power in practical as well as theoritical

1450


WHATIS TIME CONSTANT? WHATIS ITS SIGNIFICANCE? ILLUSTRATE THROUGH EXAMLES.

1671


what is the difference between oil surge relay and buchholz relay.

6429


A motor running with lenze frequiency inverter stops if I REDUCE SPEED with 25% load.If I run it in High speed and medium speed running smoothly with full load.please help me to solve it.

1526


How to measure current and voltage in an ELV circuit

3620






what is the safe meggar values for motor, transformer HT, LT and Cables? IF we want to replace I/C bay at our 220 kv substation which is of 140 mw load capacity bay to be replaced by 400 mw capacity bay.other than CT(1200/1) what are the other equipment i have to replace. why we generally use 3.5 core cable or in other word 1/2 core for neutral and also confirm me that in balance conditiob(3 phase)current in neutral will zero

1811


how many parameters can integrate with fire alarm basically ?

1497


How to calculate wire length,size & current? ( related to control panel)

1678


can anyone show me how the 3 phase power is supplied to socket outlets?

1504


How RTCC panel is working and give single line diagram for RTCC with transformer?

2648


what kn of disc is used in 33kv,132kv,220kv,400kv,800kv transmission line

2862


what type of motor used to move a 1 ton gate? and relate ratings with load.

1352


What is pi controller?

669


How to reduce -234126219.6403 MVAr generation and by what?

1234


If Neutral Grounding Resistor (GR) failed/shorted. Is it repairable.

1155