Why we not use 2-20Ma or 1-20Ma

Answer Posted / carl_ellis

Answer 1 is correct. The ISA SP50 standard established
4-20mA worldwide as the analog control signal decades ago.

But what the answer 1 and the others miss is that using 1 or
2 mA at the low end would not provide sufficient power to
power 2 wire loop powered instruments.

2 wire loop powered instruments use about 3.6mA at 24Vdc to
power the electronics which makes the measurement and
controls the output circuitry. That's about 85mW, not a lot
of power.

1mA or 2mA of current would provide only a fraction of 85mW
available at 4mA for powering the instrument itself, and
reduce the functionality of 2 wire loop powered instruments.

Carl Ellis
Measure First

Is This Answer Correct ?    1 Yes 0 No



Post New Answer       View All Answers


Please Help Members By Posting Answers For Below Questions

why is not useing in boiler skin thermocople

4529


In turbine, what does term CDP, NI, NH, HSSOC, means

2199


HOW TO SOLVE PROBLEM WITH ENRAF LEVEL TRANSMITTER 854 ATG THAT PASSWARD DO NOT Exist INTO TRANSMITTER TO ADJUST LEVEL WITH PORTABLE PET 847, WRITTEN WRONG PASSWORD , I AM SURE THAT DEFAULT PASSWARD (W2=ENRAF2) IS THIS TRANSMITTER NEED TO REPLACE SOFTWARE AND HOW?

2969


What is limitation of the ht.of the displacer of a level trol?

1835


How to Calibrate Temperature Switch in field

799






why we r opening HOT BYPASS valve during startup of a compressor?

1596


what is orfics working in main steam line. is it increase pressure, velocity of steam flow and dicrease steam flow rate. or any other

1670


Difference between ultra sonic flow meter

1551


Tr. Wiring for calibration.

1570


why orfice is not used for main steam flow calculation

1601


what diffrence b/w plc s7200,300,400

1680


Explain pH, Conductivity.

1694


How to Calibrate Radar Level Transmitter in Field

731


Operational amplifiers

1517


How to calibrate radar type level transmitter for interface level? Total liquid(liq.1 and liq.2), level both the liq individually? For. Both the liquid levels how the signal will go from transmitter to dcs? How to calibrate. Single radar 9:26:55 AM for 2 different liquids in a tank?

1578