Browse  |   Placement Papers  |   Company  |   Code Snippets  |   Certifications  |   Visa Questions Post Question  |   Post Answer  |   My Panel  |   Search  |   Articles  |   Topics  |   ERRORS new
 Did you received any Funny E-Mails from your Friends and like to share with rest of our friends? Yeah!! you can post that stuff   HERE

 Categories  >>  Engineering  >>  Instrumentation

 Civil Engineering Interview Questions Mechanical Engineering Interview Questions Electrical Engineering Interview Questions Electronics Communications Interview Questions Chemical Engineering Interview Questions Aeronautical Engineering Interview Questions Bio Engineering Interview Questions Metallurgy Interview Questions Industrial Engineering Interview Questions Instrumentation Interview Questions Automobile Engineering Interview Questions Mechatronics Engineering Interview Questions Marine Engineering Interview Questions Power Plant Engineering Interview Questions Engineering AllOther Interview Questions
Question
`why 4-20 mA signal is preferred over a 0-10V signal`
Question Submitted By :: Abhianv
I also faced this Question!!     Rank Answer Posted By

Re: why 4-20 mA signal is preferred over a 0-10V signal
# 1
generally in a transister some amount of voltage is
required for turning it on. this voltage is the cutin
voltage. up to this voltage the exists a nonlinerity in its
charecteristics. beyond this cutin voltage the char. of
transister is linear. this nonlinear region lies between 0-
4ma,beyond 4ma it linear. this is why 4-20 ma range is used.

 Is This Answer Correct ? 56 Yes 87 No
Satishpatel

Re: why 4-20 mA signal is preferred over a 0-10V signal
# 2
the signal are transmitted from the field to the
controlroom and vseversa through cables. for long
transmission the cable resistance increases.thus if 0-10v
are transmitted over this long distance,due to the
resistance of cable there will be drop in the voltage and
the signal received at the controlroom will not be
accurate. to overcome this difficulty 4-20ma signal is used
for transmission.

 Is This Answer Correct ? 233 Yes 20 No
Satishpatel

Re: why 4-20 mA signal is preferred over a 0-10V signal
# 3
Voltage drops due to Resistance and so we are using 4-20 mA
 Is This Answer Correct ? 66 Yes 8 No
Akg D Gr8

Re: why 4-20 mA signal is preferred over a 0-10V signal
# 4
If 0-10 mA is used instead of 4-20mA then there will be
difficulties in error detection.Such as if there is any
fault is the transmission lines..we will never know,wheather
the indicated 0mA current corresponds to the initial
value(calibrated) of the measurement or it is due to fault
in transmission lines.

 Is This Answer Correct ? 106 Yes 16 No
Supratim Samanta

Re: why 4-20 mA signal is preferred over a 0-10V signal
# 5
4-20mA :-
1. Easy to find the open circuit.
2. Less noise interference.
3. Current measures remain same in any point of the signal
line.

0-10V :-
This not able to fulfill the above criteria.

So that 4-20mA is preferred over 0-10v

 Is This Answer Correct ? 92 Yes 8 No
Ibrahim S

Re: why 4-20 mA signal is preferred over a 0-10V signal
# 6
0-10V :-
1. Voltage droup occurs.
2. Not able to find open circuit(Normally the circuit in
open condition o/p is "0", In 0-10V signal level starts
from 0V itself, so that can not able to find open circuit
easily)
3. Noise interference is high.

4-20mA :-
1. Easy to find the open circuit(because this signal level
starts from 4mA, if the circuit in open the output shows
0mA, so we can find easily the open circuit) .
2. Less noise interference.
3. Current measures remain same in any point of the signal
line.

So that 4-20mA is preferred over 0-10v

 Is This Answer Correct ? 71 Yes 6 No
Ibrahim S

Re: why 4-20 mA signal is preferred over a 0-10V signal
# 7
In case of voltage transmission(here 0-10V)
1.there will be voltage drop along the transmission wire.
2.if we use 0 volt then we will be unable to find whether
the obtained 0 volt output is really the system output or
its due to instrument error.So for "live zero" concept we
need to give a particular value(other than zero) in the
lower range value.
3.Capacitive and magnetic effect due to voltage
transmission will be more than that in case of current
transmission.
4.2-wire transmission is not compatible with voltage
transmission.

But in case of 4-20 mA signal the above problems are solved.
1.In series transmission same current flows through the
ckt.So no current drop occurs.
2.Here the lower range value is 4 mA.So we can easily
detect after looking at the o/p whether the instrument
error occurs or not.In case of instrument error zero
3.2-wire transmission is compatible with it.

 Is This Answer Correct ? 45 Yes 5 No
Banibrata

Re: why 4-20 mA signal is preferred over a 0-10V signal
# 8
In industry, the distance from controlroom
and the field is too long. If we use 0-10v signal
for feedback means voltagedrop will occur because of the
resistivity. So, 4-20mA is preferred instand of 0-10v
signal.

 Is This Answer Correct ? 24 Yes 5 No
A.muthu Kumar, Vacon

Re: why 4-20 mA signal is preferred over a 0-10V signal
# 9
in 4- 20
we can find if the process variables give zero because zero
is indicate 4ma
but in 0 - 10 if the process give zero we can not know
because the signal also 0v

 Is This Answer Correct ? 21 Yes 10 No
Elsayem

Re: why 4-20 mA signal is preferred over a 0-10V signal
# 10
4-20mA can be easily detected for find a minimum and maximum
level measurement. in in 0-10 V some noise if we are not
prepared measurement

 Is This Answer Correct ? 9 Yes 4 No
Luki Satria

  Question Asked @ Answers Other Instrumentation Interview Questions in the flow caluclation k value how to caluclate.mass flow & volum flow. 1 what is difference between wheatstone bridge, pirani gauge and strain gauge ??? explain its principle and working 4 What is PLC(programmable logic control)? 1 Is there any temperature compenasation for the air flow from FD fan & SA fans which supplies air to the Boiler? 2 How can we calibrate pressure and flow transmitter in the field(online)? Reddy-Labs 2 What is the Difference between E/P Positioner and I/P positioner in a control valve? In which applications the respective positioners are used in? ADCO 12 how to calculate temp.prapotional to mv in thermocoulpe. KNPC 1 what is ment by PID controllers? explain with example? 1 What is passive connection of instrument in different types of IO module? 2 whats the reason for control valve not installed -90degree (down position) 1 Why ues 250 ohms Resistor during hart type instruments calibration with hart protocol in details ? 4 how to callibrate a new i/p converter TATA 7 For more Instrumentation Interview Questions Click Here