ALLInterview.com :: Home Page            
 Advertise your Business Here     
Browse  |   Placement Papers  |   Company  |   Code Snippets  |   Certifications  |   Visa Questions
Post Question  |   Post Answer  |   My Panel  |   Search  |   Articles  |   Topics  |   ERRORS new
   Refer this Site  Refer This Site to Your Friends  Site Map  Bookmark this Site  Set it as your HomePage  Contact Us     Login  |  Sign Up                      
Google
   
 
Categories >> Engineering >> Instrumentation
 
 


 

 
 Civil Engineering interview questions  Civil Engineering Interview Questions (3070)
 Mechanical Engineering interview questions  Mechanical Engineering Interview Questions (3286)
 Electrical Engineering interview questions  Electrical Engineering Interview Questions (13320)
 Electronics Communications interview questions  Electronics Communications Interview Questions (2362)
 Chemical Engineering interview questions  Chemical Engineering Interview Questions (414)
 Aeronautical Engineering interview questions  Aeronautical Engineering Interview Questions (77)
 Bio Engineering interview questions  Bio Engineering Interview Questions (17)
 Metallurgy interview questions  Metallurgy Interview Questions (79)
 Industrial Engineering interview questions  Industrial Engineering Interview Questions (163)
 Instrumentation interview questions  Instrumentation Interview Questions (2374)
 Automobile Engineering interview questions  Automobile Engineering Interview Questions (106)
 Mechatronics Engineering interview questions  Mechatronics Engineering Interview Questions (38)
 Marine Engineering interview questions  Marine Engineering Interview Questions (43)
 Power Plant Engineering interview questions  Power Plant Engineering Interview Questions (75)
 Engineering AllOther interview questions  Engineering AllOther Interview Questions (1195)
Question
WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN PLC AND DCS
 Question Submitted By :: Instrumentation
I also faced this Question!!     Answer Posted By  
 
Answer
# 1
PLC is Progamable Logic Controller & DCS is Distributed
control system. In brief PLC using for perticular mechine or
production unit. DCS usinging for monitoring & controlling
of entire plant, including PLC.
 
Is This Answer Correct ?    523 Yes 71 No
Stanly.d'cunha
 
Answer
# 2
PLC is used Commonly with On\Off (Digital) Control and may
be expanded with Analog I\O Modules for Analog Control and
used for a Unique Task .
DCS is used Commonly with Process Control Systems as it is
Combined of Many control Cards, PLCs and Can Mange a Large
Scale Systems .
 
Is This Answer Correct ?    201 Yes 43 No
AAM
 
 
 
Answer
# 3
Plc is basically oriented for one job only,suppose if plc
fails then whole system will shut down,but in distributed
control system,you have a redundant plc for each plc so
that if primary system fails then its standby plc takes
over the charge.
 
Is This Answer Correct ?    241 Yes 85 No
Vipin
 
Answer
# 4
plc-programmable logical control,in plc program executes
searliy but in dcs all programs runs parallay.
dcs includes controller,communication and scada but plc is
a controller communication and scada softwares are to be
provided.
it ios easy to work on dcs than plc as it is having many
functions.
 
Is This Answer Correct ?    127 Yes 35 No
Dalip
 
Answer
# 5
1.PLC is for the system which need quick response.Thats why
PLC is for control of a single system with multiple control
loop,i/p and o/p
2.The response time of PLC is in millisec which is much
less than the DCS response time
 
Is This Answer Correct ?    114 Yes 34 No
Anu
 
Answer
# 6
You must automate a process, but you can't decide between a
DCS and a PLC. Are these systems really all that different?
The answers depend on a slew of other questions.


Turn the clock back 10-15 years: The programmable logic
controller (PLC) is king of machine control while the
distributed control system (DCS) dominates process control.
If you manufacture plastic widgets, you speak PLC. If you
produce chemicals, you speak DCS.

Today, the two technologies share kingdoms as the
functional lines between them continue to blur. We now use
each where the other used to rule. However, PLCs still
dominate high-speed machine control, and DCSs prevail in
complex continuous processes.

The early DCS looked dramatically different from the early
PLC. Initially, the DCS performed the control functions of
the analog panel instruments it replaced, and its interface
mimicked their panel displays. DCSs then gained sequence
logic capabilities to control batch processes as well as
continuous ones. DCSs performed hundreds of analog
measurements and controlled dozens of analog outputs, using
multi-variable Proportional Integral Derivative (PID)
control. With the same 8-bit microprocessor technology that
gave rise to the DCS, PLCs began replacing conventional
relay/solid-state logic in machine control. PLCs dealt with
contact input/output (I/O) and started/stopped motors by
performing Boolean logic calculations.




The big change in DCS over the past 20 years is its move
from proprietary hardware to the personal computer (PC) and
standard LAN technologies. With each advance in PC power,
DCSs have moved up in power. PCs gave us speedy,
responsive, multi-media, windowed, operator-process
interfaces (OPI). Relational databases and spreadsheet
software enhance the ability of DCSs to store and
manipulate data. Artificial intelligence (AI) technology
gives us "smart" alarming. Today's DCS architecturally
looks much like the DCS of 20 years ago, but tomorrow's DCS
may control through networked "smart" devices-with no I/O
hardware of its own.

Most DCSs offer redundant controllers, networks, and I/Os.
Most give you "built-in" redundancy and diagnostic
features, with no need for user-written logic.

DCSs allow centralized configuration from the operator or
engineering console in the control room. You can change
programming offline, and download without restarting the
system for the change to be effective.

DCSs allow inter-controller communications. You can do data
exchange in most DCS systems ad hoc (no need for predefined
data point lists). You access data by tag name, regardless
of hardware or location.

DCSs use multi-tasking operating systems, so you can
download and run applications aside from the real-time
control functions and still do fractional-second control.
DCSs now come in "micro" systems, to price-compete with
PLCs-but with full DCS features and capabilities.

The typical DCS has integrated diagnostics and standard
display templates that automatically extend/update when
your database changes. This database is central to the
system-you don't have different databases sitting in the
controllers.

DCSs have user-friendly configuration tools, including
structured English, control block libraries, SFC
(sequential function chart), and even RLL (relay ladder
logic).

Most DCSs allow graphical configuration, provide online
diagnostics, and are self-documenting. Most provide for
user-defined control blocks or customized strategies. The
controllers execute control strategies as independent
tasks; thus, making changes to part of the control logic
has no impact on the rest.

An important difference between DCSs and PLCs is how
vendors market them. DCS vendors typically sell a complete,
working, integrated, and tested system; offering full
application implementation. They offer many services:
training, installation, field service, and integration with
your Information Technology (IT) systems. A DCS vendor
provides a server with a relational database, a LAN with
PCs for office automation, networking support and
integration of third-party applications and systems. The
DCS vendor tries to be your "one-stop shop." The PLC is
more of a "do-it-yourself" device, which is sometimes
simpler to execute.






















Programmable Logic Controllers. When PLCs were solely
replacements for hard-wired relays, they had only digital
I/O, with no operator interface or communications. Simple
operator interfaces appeared, then evolved into
increasingly complex interfaces as PLCs worked with
increasingly complex automation problems. We went from a
panel of buttons and I/O-driven lamps to PLC full-color
customized graphic displays that run on SCADA software over
a network.

PLCs now have many DCS-like control functions (e.g., PID
algorithms) and analog I/O. They've moved past their
birthplace: the digital world (switch and binary sensor
inputs and output contacts to run motors and trigger
solenoids).

PLCs are fast: They run an input-compute-output cycle in
milliseconds. On the other hand, DCSs offer fractional
second (1/2 to 1/10) control cycles. However, some DCSs
provide interrupt/event-triggered logic for high-speed
applications.

PLCs are simple, rugged computers with minimal peripherals
and simple OSs. While increasing reliability, PLC
simplicity is not conducive to redundancy. Thus, fully
redundant ("hot," automatic, bumpless) variations of PLCs,
with their added hardware and software, sometimes suffer
from a reduction in their reliability-a characteristic PLCs
are famous for.

Data exchange typically requires you to preassign data
registers and hard code their addresses into the logic. If
you add registers or need to reassign data, you typically
have to deal manually with the Domino Effect.

Typical PLC Relay Ladder Logic (RLL) languages include
function blocks that can perform complex control and math
functions (e.g., PID algorithms). Complex multi-loop
control functions (e.g., cascade management and loop
initialization) are not typical. For functions too messy to
implement in RLL, most PLCs provide a function block that
calls a user-written program (usually in BASIC or C).

PLCs typically operate as "state" machines: They read all
inputs, execute through the logic, and then drive the
outputs. The user-written logic is typically one big RLL
program, which means you may have to take the whole PLC off-
line to make a change of any size. You also run into
database synchronization problems because of the separation
of PLCs and the Man Machine Interface (MMI) software
packages, as opposed to the central databases of DCSs.

A PLC will run in a stand-alone configuration. A DCS
controller normally expects an operator interface and
communications, so it can send alarms, messages, trend
updates, and display updates.

Many PLC installations use interface software from third-
party vendors for improved graphics and various levels of
alarming, trending, and reporting. The PLC and MMI software
normally interact by sitting on the network and using the
register exchange mechanism to get data from and to the
various PLCs. This type of communication presumes you have
preassigned data registers and can fetch data on an
absolute address basis. This can lead to data processing
errors (e.g., from the wrong input) you won't encounter
with the central database of a DCS.

Some PLCs use proprietary networks, and others can use
LANs. Either way, the communication functions are the same-
fetch and put registers. This can result in bottlenecking
and timing problems if too many PCs try communicating with
too many PLCs over a network.

A PLC may have a third-party package for operator
interfaces, LAN interface to PCs and peripherals, PLC data
highway or bus, redundant controllers with local and
distributed I/O, local MMI and local programming
capability. The PLC would have redundant media support, but
not the redundant communication hardware or I/O bus
hardware you'd find in a DCS. A PLC would have
preprogrammed I/O cards for specific signal types and
ranges.

Today, the decision between PLC and DCS often depends on
business issues rather than technical features. Questions
to consider are those involving:

The internal expertise to execute the project,
Level of support available from a vendor/integrator,
Long-term maintainability, and
Life-cycle costs.

PLCs and DCSs overlap in their features, but also have
distinct strengths and weaknesses. When deciding between
the two, know who will deliver and support your system, and
how they will do it.
 
Is This Answer Correct ?    77 Yes 6 No
Utpal
 
Answer
# 7
DCS is a number of PLC's Distributed over a Control Network
over the entire plant.
 
Is This Answer Correct ?    181 Yes 140 No
Sai
 
Answer
# 8
In DCS, field I/O points can be away from the control
processor,(where as program/logic resides)its a integarted
system includes other PLC's and Stand-alone controllers for
application specific mechine or process and having large
memory for trending & Historical alarms.PLC must be a fast
scan cycle application oriented, simple system without
human meachine interface(such as process mimics/graphics)
 
Is This Answer Correct ?    66 Yes 25 No
Varathan
 
Answer
# 9
1) PLC can not handle complicated loops and can not give
accurate result of close loops, it is only useful for very
simple application loops; while DCS can handle very complex
cascade loops and give very accurate controls to process
equipment using some inbuilt or predefined algorithms in
programming.

2) PLC has limitation in expansion of closed loops; While
DCS can handle no. of closed loops without any interruption.

3) PLC is useful for very small plant application; while
DCS is useful for integration of small-small plant and to
bring those all on a single platform.
 
Is This Answer Correct ?    15 Yes 3 No
Palak Majmudar
 
Answer
# 10
PlC has to read all its data itself and to generate o/p
accordingly,if the system is big the scan cycle goes high
and any changes in i/p could scan & dispaly little late.DCS
have many sub processor who update their data and give
summery to DCS,so DCS have to scan only these sub cpu hence
it improves the scan cycle and system becomes faster.Now PLC
has also coming with big data handling capacity with low
scan cycle.
 
Is This Answer Correct ?    15 Yes 6 No
Gyani
 

 
 
 
Other Instrumentation Interview Questions
 
  Question Asked @ Answers
 
how to calculate interface capelary level transmetar lower S.G.0.54 and uper S.G. 0.26 and h=490 mm   2
why to use 3 wire at RTD ? what's the reason for common wire ?   3
what is the conversion factor for nm3 to kg/hr in air flow   3
how many type of plug are used in pneumatic control valve,name them. Godrej 2
what is the tempareture conpensation?what is the use of this?   1
how can be connected thermocouple in series?what is the need? Hindalco 1
My friend has faced this question! I don't know clearly. So please anyone give me the correct and short answer to this question? What is variable frequency drive? Types, what is star to delta? Why this arrangement necessary? Asian-Paints 5
For an Instrumentation Engineer, is there any effect on Instruments of safety zones like zone0, zone1, zone2. As an instrumentation Engineer, what we have to consider or remember while working in these areas.( zones 0,1,2).   1
The DCS stand for________________________. it is composed of the following major components: a:______________ b:______________ c:______________ d:______________   2
why we use 4-20 mA to do calibration of the instruments.why we cant use 0-20 mA? Emerson 7
what is difference between positioner and position transmitter in control valve   1
WHICH INSTRUMENT USED TO CALIBRATE CONTROL VALVE? Honeywell 23
 
For more Instrumentation Interview Questions Click Here 
 
 
 
 
 


   
Copyright Policy  |  Terms of Service  |  Articles  |  Site Map  |  RSS Site Map  |  Contact Us
   
Copyright 2013  ALLInterview.com.  All Rights Reserved.

ALLInterview.com   ::  KalAajKal.com